Matching and Winning? The Impact of Upper and Middle Managers on Firm Performance in Major League Baseball

Abstract

We investigate the joint impact of managers at different hierarchical levels on firm performance in Major League Baseball. We separately quantify the contribution of upper and middle managers and the impact of their match quality—the degree to which managers cooperate effectively across layers to impact firm success. We establish that match quality is a statistically significant and economically meaningful driver of firm performance. Higher-quality managers tend to be matched together across levels and achieve higher match quality during their joint employment. Match quality does not improve over the length of a joint employment spell, but lower match quality is found in pairs with more divergent educational attainment and prior strategic approaches. Hence, match quality is partly innate, and manager pairings may have difficulty improving their cooperation through learning. When we control for match quality, we find significantly lower estimates of heterogeneity in manager ability compared with commonly used estimators of managerial impact. Still, both middle and upper managers retain a meaningful impact on firm performance. This paper was accepted by Bruno Cassiman, business strategy.

The Survival of Mediocre Superstars in the Labor Market

“…We therefore reestimate the model weighing observations by the number of days between the date of the game and the estimation month (see 'weight' below). We finally report results from a two-stage estimation procedure introduced by Jackson ( 2013) to allow for firm-worker match quality (see Jackson, 2013, Lazear et al, 2015and Peeters et al, 2020. In this approach, referred to as 'Spell' below, we estimate firmworker spell effects in the first stage, and then split these into worker and firm effects using weighted least squares with inverse first stage standard errors as weights.…”

Professional Labor Markets in the Journal of Sports Economics

“…This indicates the presence of superstar effects in Italian football. Outside of soccer, Peeters et al (2020) find evidence of assortative matching in the market for field managers and general managers in MLB.…”

Driving cooperative actions: A multimethod study of the temporal duration of unilateral commitments

“…Professional sports are commonly used as a source of data in the management literature (Fonti & Maoret, 2016; Hill et al, 2017; Peeters et al, 2020) due to the detail, accuracy, and completeness of data (Sirmon et al, 2008) and because of their applicability to the business world (Aime et al, 2010). Certain professional sports have significant unilateral commitments made by teams to players.…”