Mapping global trends in vaccine confidence and investigating barriers to vaccine uptake: a large-scale retrospective temporal modelling study

Abstract

Background There is growing evidence of vaccine delays or refusals due to a lack of trust in the importance, safety, or effectiveness of vaccines, alongside persisting access issues. Although immunisation coverage is reported administratively across the world, no similarly robust monitoring system exists for vaccine confidence. In this study, vaccine confidence was mapped across 149 countries between 2015 and 2019.Methods In this large-scale retrospective data-driven analysis, we examined global trends in vaccine confidence using data from 290 surveys done between September, 2015, and December, 2019, across 149 countries, and including 284 381 individuals. We used a Bayesian multinomial logit Gaussian process model to produce estimates of public perceptions towards the safety, importance, and effectiveness of vaccines. Associations between vaccine uptake and a large range of putative drivers of uptake, including vaccine confidence, socioeconomic status, and sources of trust, were determined using univariate Bayesian logistic regressions. Gibbs sampling was used for Bayesian model inference, with 95% Bayesian highest posterior density intervals used to capture uncertainty.Findings Between November, 2015, and December, 2019, we estimate that confidence in the importance, safety, and effectiveness of vaccines fell in Afghanistan, Indonesia, Pakistan, the Philippines, and South Korea. We found significant increases in respondents strongly disagreeing that vaccines are safe between 2015 and 2019 in six countries: Afghanistan, Azerbaijan, Indonesia, Nigeria, Pakistan, and Serbia. We find signs that confidence has improved between 2018 and 2019 in some EU member states, including Finland, France, Ireland, and Italy, with recent losses detected in Poland. Confidence in the importance of vaccines (rather than in their safety or effectiveness) had the strongest univariate association with vaccine uptake compared with other determinants considered. When a link was found between individuals' religious beliefs and uptake, findings indicated that minority religious groups tended to have lower probabilities of uptake.Interpretation To our knowledge, this is the largest study of global vaccine confidence to date, allowing for crosscountry comparisons and changes over time. Our findings highlight the importance of regular monitoring to detect emerging trends to prompt interventions to build and sustain vaccine confidence.Funding European Commission, Wellcome, and Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council.

Vaccination strategies for measles control and elimination: time to strengthen local initiatives

“…2 b). Other socio-economic and cultural factors have recently been found to be consistently associated with higher vaccination uptake around the globe, including high confidence in vaccines, high trust in health care workers, higher levels of science education, younger age and high information-seeking behaviour, while in some countries, belonging to a minority religious group or refusing to state religious belief was associated with lower uptake [ 22 ]. Even when mothers are willing to accept vaccination, coverage may be low due to health systems barriers such as inadequate communications about vaccination, unreliability of sessions and high transport costs to reach them [ 23 ].…”

The intention to be vaccinated against COVID-19: stated preferences before vaccines were available

“…However, it is necessary but not sufficient that vaccines are safe and effectivepeople must also be willing to be vaccinated. De Figueiredo et al (2020) estimate global trends in vaccine confidence in a large-scale study for 149 countries between 2015 and 2019. They argue that there is growing evidence that the willingness to be vaccinated is reduced or delayed because of a lack of trust in relevance, safety, and efficacy of vaccines.…”

Anti-vaccine attitudes and risk factors for not agreeing to vaccination against COVID-19 amongst 32,361 UK adults: Implications for public health communications

“…2 However, the current pandemic is occurring amidst a backdrop of widespread mistrust in the safety and effectiveness of vaccines globally. 3 Thousands of people have taken to the streets around the world to protest COVID-19 social distancing policies and the prospect of mass vaccinations. This is concerning as public attitudes towards vaccine safety, their importance, and effectiveness are consistently associated with vaccine uptake.…”

“…This is concerning as public attitudes towards vaccine safety, their importance, and effectiveness are consistently associated with vaccine uptake. 3 Although general population data from the UK and Europe indicate mostly positive attitudes towards vaccines, research is suggesting there is still a substantial (≅ 10%) proportion of adults who are unsure of or distrust the safety and effectiveness of vaccines in the UK and Europe general population. 4 Findings from nationally representative studies suggest unwillingness and uncertainty about receiving a COVID-19 vaccine will be a significant challenge in achieving the vaccination coverage required for population immunity.…”