Mainstreaming Community Energy: Is the Renewable Energy Directive a Driver for Renewable Energy Communities in Germany and Italy?

Abstract

By 30 June 2021, EU Member States were expected to transpose the recast Renewable Energy Directive (RED II) which includes provisions for renewable energy communities (RECs) and to develop an enabling framework to promote the development of RECs. Although there is a growing number of studies analysing the emergence of various forms of community energy, comparative studies investigating the transposition and creation of enabling frameworks for RECs in a multi-level governance (MLG) perspective are scarce. This article examines the transposition in Germany and Italy and compares elements of the respective enabling frameworks. Key methods include context and MLG analysis combined with methods of descriptive (legal) studies. Insights and participatory observations of the stakeholder desks established in the Horizon2020 project COME RES complement the spectrum of methods deployed. Although community energy development is more advanced in Germany, the transposition of the RED II provisions has been slow and piecemeal so far. Conversely, in Italy, RED II played a catalyst role; the transposition has been rather dynamic and encouraged a continuous growth of REC initiatives. Nevertheless, a widespread uptake of RECs requires structural adjustments of the governance system in both countries and attention to MLG as well as vertical policy coordination.

What Can We Expect for the Development of Rural Areas in Europe?—Trends of the Last Decade and Their Opportunities for Rural Regeneration

“…However, realizing such visions requires targeted support for local solutions and place-based strategies (see also Section 4.4), because each region has different conditions for different types of renewable energy in terms of availability and negative impacts on residents and the environment. In this context, renewable energy communities play an important role in the transition from centralized power plants towards a more distributed energy production [77].…”

Quo vadis, Deutschland? Stand und Perspektiven der Nachhaltigkeitspolitik

“…Allerdings wurden die Möglichkeiten für Bürger:innen, sich an der Energiewende (finanziell) zu beteiligen, in den letzten Jahren immer mehr zugunsten großer Energiekonzerne eingeschränkt und erst kürzlich wieder verbessert (vgl. Krug et al 2022). Es ist also eine empirische und keine Frage der Haltung zum Populismus, ob man das Attribut ›Elitenprojekt‹ für angemessen hält oder nicht.…”

Virtual energy sharing and energy communities for the Municipality of Milan: The case of the Chiaravalle area

“…National funds, such as those from the National Plan for Complementary Investments (PNC), support programs like "NextAppennino", allocating 68 million euros to create energy communities in seismic areas [18]. The PNRR allocates 2.2 billion euros for REC promotion in municipalities with fewer than 5000 inhabitants through the M2C2 measure [19], [20]. Despite setbacks, these initiatives reflect a growing commitment to foster REC development in Italy.…”