Machine learning in project analytics: a data-driven framework and case study

Abstract

The analytic procedures incorporated to facilitate the delivery of projects are often referred to as project analytics. Existing techniques focus on retrospective reporting and understanding the underlying relationships to make informed decisions. Although machine learning algorithms have been widely used in addressing problems within various contexts (e.g., streamlining the design of construction projects), limited studies have evaluated pre-existing machine learning methods within the delivery of construction projects. Due to this, the current research aims to contribute further to this convergence between artificial intelligence and the execution construction project through the evaluation of a specific set of machine learning algorithms. This study proposes a machine learning-based data-driven research framework for addressing problems related to project analytics. It then illustrates an example of the application of this framework. In this illustration, existing data from an open-source data repository on construction projects and cost overrun frequencies was studied in which several machine learning models (Python’s Scikit-learn package) were tested and evaluated. The data consisted of 44 independent variables (from materials to labour and contracting) and one dependent variable (project cost overrun frequency), which has been categorised for processing under several machine learning models. These models include support vector machine, logistic regression, k-nearest neighbour, random forest, stacking (ensemble) model and artificial neural network. Feature selection and evaluation methods, including the Univariate feature selection, Recursive feature elimination, SelectFromModel and confusion matrix, were applied to determine the most accurate prediction model. This study also discusses the generalisability of using the proposed research framework in other research contexts within the field of project management. The proposed framework, its illustration in the context of construction projects and its potential to be adopted in different contexts will significantly contribute to project practitioners, stakeholders and academics in addressing many project-related issues.

Confirming the statistically significant superiority of tree-based machine learning algorithms over their counterparts for tabular data

“…It is evident in the literature that tree-based ML algorithms can handle non-linear classification datasets better [ 13 ], which could be a possible reason for their performance superiority. Uddin and Lu [ 41 ] noticed that dataset meta-level and statistical attributes do not impact the performance of tree-based MLs. However, they have a statistically significant impact on non-tree-based ML algorithms.…”

“…While our findings suggest tree-based algorithms outperform non-tree-based ones across multiple datasets, we recognise the importance of considering dataset-specific characteristics, such as feature distribution and complexity, that could influence algorithm performance. Uddin and Lu [ 41 ] discovered that ML algorithms exhibit varying performances when applied to datasets with distinct meta-level and statistical attributes. Moreover, an explanatory approach, combined with domain expertise, could unearth the factors contributing to the superiority of tree-based algorithms.…”

Decoding bilingualism from resting‐state oscillatory network organization

“…This algorithm incorporates regularization in its boosting process, thus mitigating overfitting and enhancing the generalizability of the results. Recognized for its outstanding performance and speed, XGBoost has become a dominant algorithm in applied machine learning 49 . A recent state‐of‐the‐art comparison of classification algorithms 50 underscores XGBoost's effectiveness across both small and large training sets—consistently outperforming more popular classifiers such as support vector machine and random forest.…”

A robust and resilience machine learning for forecasting agri-food production

“…Changing the constraint is still the model becomes Linear Programming (LP). As a result, this type of function is generated to control the performance of the main model: 5)- (13).…”