It has been widely accepted and experimentally verified that electron emission in high-current diodes with metal, dielectric (velvet), and carbon fiber cathodes is due to the formation of a plasma on the cathode surface at the beginning of the high voltage pulse applied to the diode. 1 Field emission may play a role as a precursor and then as a supplier of electrons to the plasma but does not contribute directly to the electron flow ejected into the anode-cathode space.A recent publication by Shiffler et al. 2 proposes, however, that the cesium iodide (CsI) coated carbon velvet cathodes operate in a space charge limited regime with pure field emission alone and the cathode plasma has a minor, if any, role in the electron flow generation. In that paper, the planar diode with the CsI carbon velvet cathode and the stainless steel anode having a cathode-anode gap of 4 cm was investigated. The applied voltage pulse was ϳ 180 kV amplitude, ϳ 1.3 s full width at half maximum duration and the electron current was ϳ1.7 kA (current density of j e ϳ 11 A/cm 2 ). The emphasis was made on optical (10 ns framing camera) and spectroscopy (light accumulation during ϳ10 3 pulses) observations of light emitted perpendicular to the diode axis.A major conclusion about the pure field emission being the sole mechanism for the diode electron current generation was made on the basis of the following experimental observations.(i) No impedance collapse and no light emission from the diode interelectrode space were detected during the highvoltage pulse.