Love Redirected: On Adam Smith's Love of Praiseworthiness

Abstract

Why be moral? Why, in the language of Adam Smith, act on what you think is praiseworthy even when it does not get you praise from other people? Because, answers Smith, you love praiseworthiness. But what is this love of praiseworthiness, and where does it come from? In this article, 1) I argue that we start to love praiseworthiness when we redirect our love of praise away from other people toward the ‘impartial spectator’-aspect of ourselves, and 2) show how this fits with evidence that the rudimentary moral compass which guides us early in childhood needs correction through socialisation to develop into a mature moral conscience.

Choosing Less over More Money

“…Sivertsen (2017) offers an interesting discussion on how the love of praiseworthiness may have evolved and contrasts his view withHanley (2009), claiming that the love of praiseworthiness is a love redirected in the sense that our desire to be approved by others teaches us to view ourselves as others see us, how they would judge us had they been better informed, and how they should judge us as impartial spectators. A similar argument is offered byUyl and Griswold Jr (1996).…”