Losing Weight on Reality TV: A Content Analysis of the Weight Loss Behaviors and Practices Portrayed onThe Biggest Loser

Abstract

A number of weight loss-related reality television programs chronicle the weight loss experience of obese individuals in a competitive context. Although highly popular, such shows may misrepresent the behavior change necessary to achieve substantial weight loss. A systematic, quantitative content analysis of Seasons 10-13 (n = 66 episodes) of The Biggest Loser was conducted to determine the amount of time and number of instances that diet, physical activity, or other weight management strategies were presented. The average episode was 78.8 ± 15.7 min in length. Approximately 33.3% of an episode, representing 1,121 segments, portrayed behavioral weight management-related content. Within the episode time devoted to weight management content, 85.2% was related to physical activity, 13.5% to diet, and 1.2% to other. Recent seasons of The Biggest Loser suggest that substantial weight loss is achieved primarily through physical activity, with little emphasis on modifying diet and eating behavior. Although physical activity can impart substantial metabolic health benefits, it may be difficult to create enough of an energy deficit to induce significant weight loss in the real world. Future studies should examine the weight loss attitudes and behaviors of obese individuals and health professionals after exposure to reality television shows focused on weight loss.

Remote Acculturation and Physical Activity Among Adolescent-Mother Dyads in Jamaica: A Developmental Dyadic Moderation

“…The content and messaging about physical activity in television programs is, therefore, relevant to understanding how orientation to U.S. culture may relate to physical activity levels. Although there are high rates of obesity and sedentary behavior in the United States, actors and television personalities in U.S. media are disproportionately thin and toned (Robinson et al, 2008), and U.S. television programs that specifically depict weight loss may highlight physical activity as the main strategy for controlling body weight, while underrepresenting the role of diet (Klos et al, 2015). A recent content analysis of four programs targeting adolescent audiences found that physical activity was portrayed in half of the programs studied, and it was generally depicted as a positive activity motivated by enjoyment (O'Reilly-Duff et al, 2018).…”

When fat meets disability in poverty porn: exploring the cultural mechanisms of suspicion inToo Fat to Work

“…Not only has health become something one does, but correct and visible performances become markers of mature, moral personhood and responsible citizenship (Gard and Wright 2005). In this context, the possession of a fat body is a visible mark of a stigmatised identity (Monaghan, Bombak, and Rich 2017;Aphramor 2005): overweight or obese people are always and already regarded as 'health offenders' (Tischner 2013,5) whose health problems are considered selfinflicted (Klos et al, 2015). Additionally, in the context of neoliberal rationalities and particularly austerity, this 'offence' is represented as having an impact on the health care of other citizens because of the 'burden' obesity places on already overstretched (under-funded) welfare services: the fat body then, becomes a concern of us all, encouraging a degree of social acceptability towards the everyday humiliation and prejudice towards larger people to 'encourage' them into good health practices (Major 'badness and sickness' that 'fat may as well be a four letter word' (Monaghan, 2007, 605).…”

Monitoring the ‘diabetes epidemic’: A framing analysis of United Kingdom print news 1993-2013

“…Through a cascading network of issue interpretation the media are thought to play a key role in setting public understandings about a range of issues [41]. Others argue they co-construct the structures through which the public understand health and illness [42] and bolster the visibility and validity of contemporary health 'epidemics' [15,43]. Journalists admit that much of what drives reporting about health is newsworthiness and sensationalism, and that risk is a key way of garnering public attention [44].…”