Looking Back to Move Forward: First-Year Medical Students’ Meta-Reflections on Their Narrative Portfolio Writings

Abstract

The day-to-day rigors of medical education often preclude learners from gaining a longitudinal perspective on who they are becoming. Furthermore, the current focus on competencies, coupled with concerning rates of trainee burnout and a decline in empathy, have fueled the search for pedagogic tools to foster students' reflective capacity. In response, many scholars have looked to the tradition of narrative medicine to foster "reflective spaces" wherein holistic professional identity construction can be supported. This article focuses on the rationale, content, and early analysis of the reflective space created by the narrative medicine-centered portfolio at the Columbia University Vagelos College of Physicians and Surgeons. In January 2015, the authors investigated learning outcomes derived from students' "Signature Reflections," end-of-semester meta-reflections on their previous portfolio work. The authors analyzed the Signature Reflections of 97 (of 132) first-year medical students using a constant comparative process. This iterative approach allowed researchers to identify themes within students' writings and interpret the data. The authors identified two overarching interpretive themes-recognition and grappling-and six subthemes. Recognition included comments about self-awareness and empathy. Grappling encompassed the subthemes of internal change, dichotomies, wonder and questioning, and anxiety. Based on the authors' analyses, the Signature Reflection seems to provide a structured framework that encourages students' reflective capacity and the construction of holistic professional identity. Other medical educators may adopt meta-reflection, within the reflective space of a writing portfolio, to encourage students' acquisition of a longitudinal perspective on who they are becoming and how they are constructing their professional identity.

A qualitative study of the impact of a dementia experiential learning project on pre-medical students: a friend for Rachel

“…The weekly narratives of their experiences and thoughts demonstrate the impact of AFFR on the pre-medical students. Narrative medicine has been shown to be an effective way to enhance learning and is being incorporated into medical school curricula [20]. Through journaling, students take time to process their thoughts and experiences and reflect on how they see themselves changing.…”

Analysis of Role Modeling Experiences and Reflection Level of Fourth‐Year Medical Students at a Single Medical College: A Focus on the Clinical Clerkship

“…임상실습 중 임상 교육자의 롤 모델링에 대한 태도는 개인차가 크기 에 의대생을 대상으로 하는 롤 모델링을 개선하는 노력이 필요하다 [21]. 따라서 학생들이 임상실습 중 롤 모델을 관찰하고, 상황을 비판하고, 선별적으로 받아들일 수 있도록 개인적 또는 집단적 차원 에서 성찰의 기회를 경험하는 것은 전문직 정체성 형성에 필수적인 요소이다 [22][23][24][25].…”

East meets West: Shadow coaching to support online reflective practice

“…In this project we focused on building coaches’ ability to guide students’ reflective process within the context of the Chinese medical system. Evidence shows reflection can lead to improved student self-awareness and empathy, and contribute to the development of a holistic professional identity [20]. However, as we highlighted, reflective writing and open discussion is a new paradigm for Chinese medical students and faculty, given the structure of the Chinese healthcare system and a cultural propensity for non-confrontation [10].…”