In this essay, I argue for a 'kaleidoscopic' theory of mind implicit in people's common-sense awareness of themselves, others, and reality in northern Thailand. Phenomenal experience is here generally understood as contingent on a host of factors, from personal habits to the influence of others, such that sensory perceptions themselves are in part a consequence of prior action (karma) with moral import. When Thai people convert to Christianity, they reject karma in favour of a God who will absolve a believer of all offence. Drawing on both neo-Pentecostal and Buddhist Thais' rich descriptions of their encounters with the divine and a host of other 'supernatural' experiences, I show how many Thai Christians maintain an abridged sense of karmic contingency. With attention to local theory of mind, non-monotheistic knowledge formations come into focus, highlighting the unique nature of the individualism emerging among Thai congregants and the stakes such individuation has for them.Johnny Srisak 1 explained his conversion from Buddhism to Christianity as the result of a single Bible verse: Romans 8: 5. He was a young man at the time -before his marriage, before the launch of his successful architecture career, before the birth of his now teenaged sons. First his older sister had converted, which was an anomaly then in a northern Thai family. He and his father eventually followed her lead. As we talked in the open-air portico of his now long-established Pentecostal church in the urban centre of Chiang Mai, he recalled a question that had haunted him in his youth. Was there no power in the universe that could change our fate and clear us of our wrongdoings? The question was a rail against karma, the force taken for granted in his social world, that which can limit one's life chances regardless of even the most active striving. Then one day his sister presented him Romans 8: 5: 'But God demonstrates his own love for us in this: While we were still sinners, Christ died for us' . It was the answer to his rail. Christ could alleviate all the moral wrongdoing that could not be undone directly and immediately by any other means. Johnny traded karma for sin and felt himself absolved.