Limitations of MTT and MTS-Based Assays for Measurement of Antiproliferative Activity of Green Tea Polyphenols

Abstract

BackgroundThe chemopreventive effect of green tea polyphenols, such as (-)-epigallocatechin-3-gallate (EGCG), has been well demonstrated in cell culture studies. However, a wide range of IC50 concentrations has been observed in published studies of the anti-proliferative activity of EGCG from different laboratories. Although the susceptibility to EGCG treatment is largely dependent on cancer cell type, the particular cell viability and proliferation assays utilized may significantly influence quantitative results reported in the literature.Methodology/Principal FindingsWe compared five widely used methods to measure cell proliferation and viability after EGCG treatment using LNCaP prostate cancer cells and MCF-7 breast cancer cells. Both methods using dyes to quantify adenosine triphosphate (ATP) and deoxynucleic acid (DNA) showed accuracy in the measurement of viable cells when compared to trypan blue assay and results showed good linear correlation (r = 0.95). However, the use of MTT (3-(4,5-Dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide) and MTS (3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-5-(3-carboxymethoxyphenyl)-2-(4-sulfophenyl)-2H-tetrazolium) as indicators of metabolically active mitochondria overestimated the number of viable cells by comparison with the ATP, DNA, or trypan blue determinations. As a result, the observed IC50 concentration of EGCG was 2-fold higher using MTT and MTS compared to dyes quantifying ATP and DNA. In contrast, when cells were treated with apigenin MTT and MTS assays showed consistent results with ATP, DNA, or trypan blue assays.Conclusions/SignificanceThese results demonstrate that MTT and MTS -based assays will provide an underestimation of the anti-proliferative effect of EGCG, and suggest the importance of careful evaluation of the method for in vitro assessment of cell viability and proliferation depending on the chemical nature of botanical supplements.

Stability, toxicity and intestinal permeation enhancement of two food-derived antihypertensive tripeptides, Ile-Pro-Pro and Leu-Lys-Pro

“…The MTS assay data indicate that unlabelled IPP and LKP was not cytotoxic in Caco-2 or HepG2 cells from 0.1-10mM at selected time points. The MTS assay yielded low errors, similar to the findings of others (30). A positive control, Triton®-X-100 (0.05%), massively reduced viability of both cell types at each incubation time point.…”

Assessing the In Vitro and In Vivo Toxicity of Superparamagnetic Iron Oxide Nanoparticles

“…The reason for these different results is not yet understood, especially because similar tests (MTT and MTS) lead to very different results. 129 However, such models offer an inexpensive and high-throughput alternative to in vivo research strategies. It is of utmost importance to enhance quality and reliability of in vitro studies with nanoparticles in general.…”

Viability Assays for Cells in Culture

“…The MTT assay can overestimate the number of viable cells in comparison to ATP measurements and exhibits an IC 50 that is two-fold higher 43 . Furthermore, Petty and colleagues reported that the ATP assay could detect the lower limit of 1563 cells per well whereas the MTT assay could not detect fewer than 25k cells/well 12 .…”