Background
CMR typically quantifies LV mass (LVM) via manual planimetry (MP), but this approach is time consuming and does not account for partial voxel components - myocardium admixed with blood in a single voxel. Automated segmentation (AS) can account for partial voxels, but this has not been used for LVM quantification. This study used automated CMR segmentation to test the influence of partial voxels on quantification of LVM.
Methods and Results
LVM was quantified by AS and MP in 126 consecutive patients and 10 laboratory animals undergoing CMR. AS yielded both partial voxel (ASPV) and full voxel (ASFV) measurements. Methods were independently compared to LVM quantified on echocardiography (echo) and an ex-vivo standard of LVM at necropsy. AS quantified LVM in all patients, yielding a 12-fold decrease in processing time vs. MP (0:21±0:04 vs. 4:18±1:02 min; p<0.001). ASFV mass (136±35gm) was slightly lower than MP (139±35; Δ=3±9gm, p<0.001). Both methods yielded similar proportions of patients with LV remodeling (p=0.73) and hypertrophy (p=1.00). Regarding partial voxel segmentation, ASPV yielded higher LVM (159±38gm) than MP (Δ=20±10gm) and ASFV (Δ=23±6gm, both p<0.001), corresponding to relative increases of 14% and 17%. In multivariable analysis, magnitude of difference between ASPV and ASFV correlated with larger voxel size (partial r=0.37, p<0.001) even after controlling for LV chamber volume (r=.28, p=0.002) and total LVM (r=0.19, p=0.03). Among patients, ASPV yielded better agreement with echo (Δ=20±25gm) than did ASFV (Δ=43±24gm) or MP (Δ=40±22gm, both p<0.001). Among laboratory animals, ASPV and ex-vivo results were similar (Δ=1±3gm, p=0.3), whereas ASFV (6±3gm, p<0.001) and MP (4±5gm, p=0.02) yielded small but significant differences with LVM at necropsy.
Conclusions
Automated segmentation of myocardial partial voxels yields a 14-17% increase in LVM vs. full voxel segmentation, with increased differences correlated with lower spatial resolution. Partial voxel segmentation yields improved CMR agreement with echo and necropsy-verified LVM.