Leasing and Secondary Markets: Theory and Evidence from Commercial Aircraft

Abstract

I construct a dynamic model of transactions in used capital to understand the role of leasing when trading is subject to frictions. Firms trade assets to adjust their productive capacity in response to shocks to profitability. Transaction costs hinder the efficiency of the allocation of capital, and lessors act as trading intermediaries who reduce trading frictions. The model predicts that leased assets trade more frequently and produce more output than owned assets, for two reasons. First, high-volatility firms are more likely to lease than low-volatility firms, since they expect to adjust their capacity more frequently. Second, ownership's larger transaction costs widen owners' inaction bands relative to lessees'.Using data on commercial aircraft, I find that leased aircraft have holding durations 38-percent shorter and fly 6.5-percent more hours than owned aircraft. Additional tests indicate that most of these differential patterns in trading and utilization arise because owners have wider inaction bands than lessees, and carriers' self-selection into leasing plays a minor role.

The Market for Used Capital: Endogenous Irreversibility and Reallocation Over the Business Cycle

“…• Consumption C(z, m) and labor supply N (z, m) solve the consumer's problem of maximizing (12) subject to (13) • Firms' labor demand n(k, s, z, m) satisfies equation (16) • The value functions V i , V d and V satisfy the functional equations (23), (24) and…”

A Quantitative Analysis of the Used-Car Market

“…We assume that there are transaction costs in the secondary market: If a household sells a car of age a, it pays a transaction cost λ a proportional to the sale price. 14 The level of transaction costs will be a key variable in some of our counterfactuals.…”

Pricing and Liquidity in Decentralized Asset Markets

“…To the 4 See Du¢ e (2012b). 5 The framework of Du¢ e et al (2005) has also been adopted to analyze a number of issues, such as market fragmentation (Miao, 2006), clientele e¤ects (Vayanos & Wang, 2007), the congestion e¤ect (Afonso, 2011), commercial aircraft leasing (Gavazza, 2011), liquidity in corporate bond market (He & Milbradt, 2014), the co-existence of illiquid and liquid markets (Praz, 2014), the liquidity spillover between bond and CDS markets (Sambalaibat, 2015), the supply of liquid assets (Geromichalos & Herrenbrueck, 2016), and the endogenous bargaining delays (Tsoy, 2016). 6 Other papers that use the same trading framework include Lagos, Rocheteau, and Weill (2011), Lester, Rocheteau, and Weill (2015), Pagnotta and Philippon (2015), and Randall (2015).…”

“…and non-persistence of correlation shocks. Equation (30) shows that the average OTC holding is a linear combination of the desired OTC holding and A. Using this interpretation, the fraction +2(e r( ) r) can be broadly considered to be a measure of the distortion on the extensive margin.…”