Labour and Total Factor Productivity in the Chinese Electronics Industry in the 1990s

Abstract

The Chinese Electronics Industry (CEI) is the largest industry in China interms of sales revenues and accounts for the largest amount of foreign direct investment of any industry in China. This paper provides an analysis of the industry's economic performance using panel data for the period 1993 to 1999 to calculate labour productivity, and for 1995 to 1999 to calculate total factor productivity. The analysis provides separate figures for each main ownership form in China. The results confirm that while performance under all ownership forms has improved during the 1990s, productivity in state-owned enterprises has continued to lag behind that in collectives and joint ventures, including wholly foreign-owned firms. In addition, the study finds that the move to corporatise state-owned enterprises by creating limited liability companies, with a view to improving corporate governance and therefore their management, has yet to have a noticeable effect on productivity. Limited liability companies in the CEI have a higher absolute level of productivity than traditionally-organised SOEs, but the growth rates of the two sectors did not differ much over the period studied. Also, SOEs, in traditional and limited liability forms, continue to be outperformed by the collective and joint venture sectors.

The Role of the State in China's Industrial Development: A Reassessment

“…Most of them found that private firms performed better (see Chen, 2001;Gul and Zhao, 2001;Wei and Varela, 2003;Hovey, 2005), while others were inconclusive or did not find a systemic relationship between ownership and firms' behavior (Wang, 2005). Zhang and Parker (2004) analyzed total factor productivity (TFP) trends in China's electronics industry in the 1990s, and found that corporatized SOEs did not perform significantly better than traditional ones, with TFP growing but at a slower pace than in both collective and private electronic firms. Most researchers, however, found that legal person holdings have a positive impact (see Sun and Tong, 2003;Wong et al, 2004).…”

Comparative Analysis of the Total Factor Productivity of Manufacturing in Northeast Asian Metropolitan Areas

“…They estimated productivity change, which was assumed to be a pure technical efficiency, as well as change in technique and economy of scale. Zhang and Parker (2004) estimated the labor productivity and TFP of the Chinese electronic industry. They used panel data from 1993 to 1999 to estimate labor productivity and data from 1995 to 1999 to estimate TFP.…”

The Puzzle of China's Township–Village Enterprises The Paradox of Local Corporatism in a Dual-Track Economic Transition

“…Related to its high efficiency, the collective sector, especially the TVE sub-sector, has contributed greatly to the economic reform and economic growth in China since 1978(Ma, 2000Oi, 1999). For example, the contribution of the TVE sector to the Zhang et al, 2001 Technical Efficiency Jefferson et al, 2000TFP Dong and Putterman, 1997TFP Jefferson et al, 2000TFP Growth in 1988-1992TFP Growth in 1992Zhang and Parker, 2002 Notes: POE refers to privately-owned enterprises; COE refers to collectively-owned firms; SOE refers to stateowned firms; technical efficiency is a measure of efficiency in terms of the difference between the real output and the potential output based on a stochastic production frontier model; TFP stands for total factor productivity as a measure of efficiency in terms of the ratio of the real output over all the inputs used in production.…”