Kritik Atas Kritik Kamaruddin Amin:  (Menguji Kembali Keakuratan) Metode Kritik Hadis

Ahmad, La Ode Ismail; Nasir, St. Magfirah; Ilyas, Abustani

doi:10.24252/ihyaussunnah.v1i2.29453

Cited by 2 publications

(3 citation statements)

References 0 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…However, this source of Azami's study was later considered inconsistent and only appeared in the third century of the Hijria. 27 Azami made edits to these manuscripts and then made them as valuable reference material. 28 Azami used this discovery to refute the Orientalist theory, which concluded that hadith could not be trusted historically.…”

Section: Azami's Position In Hadith Studiesmentioning

confidence: 99%

Criticism of Mustafa Azami's Critical Thoughts in Study of Hadith

Isnaeni,

Susanto,

Haqiqi

2023

ujis

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The existence and authenticity of hadith have become two of the most essential objects in the discourse of hadith among Muslims, especially after coming into contact with criticism from Orientalists. This article describes explicitly and criticizes Azami's hadith thought in the hadith debate among Orientalists. This research is an analytical descriptive research based on content analysis. The results reveal that Azami can position himself as a critic of the Western thesis by presenting historical data as a basis for his thoughts. The rhythm of the scientific debate modeled on by Western thinkers can be dived into and followed convincingly so that their responses and criticisms reach the Orientalists. Orientalists believe that Azami's criticism has not been able to divert the orientation of the general thesis that hadiths are not historically authentic. Azami's defense still needs convincing, and the arguments are still circular. This model of thinking has yet to satisfy the scientific desires of the Orientalists, so it has a small implications.

show abstract

Section: Azami's Position In Hadith Studiesmentioning

confidence: 99%

Criticism of Mustafa Azami's Critical Thoughts in Study of Hadith

Isnaeni,

Susanto,

Haqiqi

2023

ujis

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Setalah melakukan kajian terhadap Isnad Family, Azami menyimpulkan bahwa sistem Isnad dapat dipercaya, namun tidak dapat dijadikan kriteria hadis sahih (Amin, 2009). Pandangan Azami, family Isnad yaitu tidak semuanya palsu dan tidak pula semuanya benar.…”

Section: Explosive Isnad Dan Isnad Familyunclassified

“…Di kajian sanad, Abbot dan Azami memiliki pendapat yang sama bahwa hadis telah ditulis pada masa kenabian (Amin, 2009). Walaupun pendapat ini sering ditentang oleh para orientalis dengan alasan adanya pelarangan penulisan hadis pada masa Umar Bin Khattab.…”

Section: Explosive Isnad Dan Isnad Familyunclassified

Explosive Isnad and Isnad Family: Thoughts of Mustafa Azami and Nabia Abbott

Iqbal

Husna

Nurkholis

2021

CJSI

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Ismologists Nabia Abbott and Mustafa Azami specialize in the study of hadith. Many of their works refute orientalist claims that the Prophet's hadith was compiled by Companions and generations in the second and third centuries. The purpose of this research is to glance at Mustafa Azami's and Nabia Abbott's opinions on the Explosive Isnad and the Isnad Family, as well as how they compare to the views of classical hadith scholars. This study employs a literature review method. The findings show that most of Abbott and Azami's viewpoints are similar to those of hadith scholars, such as in the context of the increasing number of hadith narrations in each generation and the fact that the family isnad cannot be used as a criterion for determining the validity of a hadith. The difference is in Abbott's interpretation of the Sunnah.

show abstract

Kritik Atas Kritik Kamaruddin Amin: (Menguji Kembali Keakuratan) Metode Kritik Hadis

Cited by 2 publications

References 0 publications

Criticism of Mustafa Azami's Critical Thoughts in Study of Hadith

Criticism of Mustafa Azami's Critical Thoughts in Study of Hadith

Explosive Isnad and Isnad Family: Thoughts of Mustafa Azami and Nabia Abbott

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About