Kaibel column: Modeling, optimization, and conceptual design of multi-product dividing wall columns

Abstract

In this work, we present the modeling, optimization, and conceptual design of a dividing wall column for the separation of four products, commonly referred to in the literature as a Kaibel column. For its solution, we propose and validate a rigorous tray-by-tray model, followed by its reformulation to include a mixed-integer nonlinear programming and a general disjunctive programming formulation to respond to the conceptual design problem attached to these complex configurations. Considering the validated model and the two formulations, the Kaibel column is solved, obtaining four high-purity products and new optimal tray locations for the feed and two side product streams, when the mixed-integer nonlinear programming formulation is applied. The use of these optimally located side streams showed reductions in the energy consumption when compared to cases were non-optimal fixed tray locations are used. When the general disjunctive programming problem was solved, the minimum number of trays needed in the main column and dividing wall are obtained, showing a great reduction of the remixing effects in the Kaibel column, and with that, a more energy efficient configuration. The models were coded in Pyomo using the solver IPOPT for the solution of the nonlinear programming problem, the solver Bonmin for the solution of the mixedinteger nonlinear programming problem, and GDPopt for the solution of the general disjunctive programming optimization problem.

The IDAES process modeling framework and model library—Flexibility for process simulation and optimization

“…While the case study shown here is relatively simple, the IDAES-CMF has been applied to simulating and optimizing complex chemical and energy related processes, such as the removal of CO 2 from power plant flue gas. [38] The IDAES-CMF has also been applied to a range of other problem types, such as conceptual design and process intensification [39] and dynamic real-time optimization and control, [40] and non-linear robust optimization. [41] F I G U R E 1 8 Distribution of capital and operating cost with respect to the uncertainty considered in the kinetic parameters…”

Equation-Oriented Optimization of a Distillation Column Considering Stage Hydraulics

“…Luyben demonstrated that the energy consumption of distillation columns can increase, instead of decrease, when more stages are used due to the pressure drop increase by the addition of stage(s). Second, in the thermally coupled distillation configurations, like those in dividing wall columns (DWCs) or side rectifier columns, which are appearing economically attractive and have drawn much attention recently, − vapor split must take place, and the distribution of the split vapor flows up into the two corresponding column sections is a direct result of the balance between the pressure drops of the two column sections …”

A comprehensive economic optimization methodology of divided wall columns for biopolyol separation

“…To handle disturbance and implementation error of DWCs, Luo et al [22] developed an online optimization method assisted with steady-state analysis. In addition, a sequential quadratic method using the mixed integer linear programming problem [23] or MINLP [24] approach was also used for conceptual design of DWCs. However, this kind of method is difficult to implement.…”