Abstract:In the last five decades, the number of women behind bars in the United States has risen exponentially. It is now estimated that there are nearly 58,000 admissions of pregnant people—disproportionately women of color—to jails and prisons each year. Recognizing the urgency and consequences of mass incarceration on pregnant people, their families, and communities, House Resolution 948: Justice for Incarcerated Moms Act of 2021 was introduced to Congress as a part of the Black Maternal Health Momnibus. The Justic… Show more
“…Estelle vs. Gamble (1976) established that all incarcerated persons are entitled to health care for "serious medical needs;" however, adherence to professional standards for perinatal care in carceral settings (e.g., ACOG, 2021;NCCHC, 2020;Sufrin, 2018) is not monitored or enforced, resulting in varied policies, programs, and outcomes across the U.S. (Buchanan, 2012). State and federal initiatives have begun to expand support for women who are incarcerated during pregnancy (Kotlar et al, 2015;Schroeder & Bell, 2005); however services vary widely in their accessibly and provision of care (Shlafer et al, 2022;Wilson et al, 2022). Indeed, it is notable that even amongst the growing body of literature on enhanced perinatal programs in carceral settings (e.g., Wilson et al, 2022), comprehensive programs specifically targeting mental health and addiction amongst this population are rare (Steely Smith, Wilson et al, 2023a;Steely Smith et al, 2023b).…”
Background
The extraordinary growth in women’s incarceration over the past several decades has resulted in calls for expansion of research into their unique needs and experiences, including those related to pregnancy and perinatal care. However, while research into the health outcomes of women who are incarcerated while pregnant has grown, research on women’s custodial and perinatal care patterns has remained nearly non-existent. Here, we sought to describe (1) the characteristics of the population of women who came to be incarcerated in a state prison system during pregnancy and (2) the characteristics of women’s custodial and perinatal care patterns during and after incarceration.
Methods
We conducted a retrospective chart review of the population of women who received perinatal care while incarcerated in the Arkansas state prison system over a 5-year period from June 2014 to May 2019. Electronic medical records and state prison records were merged to form our study population. Data were from 212 women (Mage = 28.4 years; 75.0% non-Latina White) with a singleton pregnancy who received at least one obstetric care visit while incarcerated.
Results
Drug-related convictions were the most common crimes leading to women’s incarceration while pregnant, and violent crime convictions were rare. Nearly half (43.4%) of women who gave birth in custody did so within 90 days of admission and the great majority (80.4%) released within 1-year of giving birth, including 13.3% who released within 30 days.
Discussion
The frequency with which women who became incarcerated while pregnant released from prison either prior to or shortly after giving birth was a striking, novel finding of this study given the implications for perinatal care disruption among a high-risk population and the harms of forced separation from infants within hours of birth.
Conclusions
Diversionary programs for pregnant women convicted of crimes, particularly in states without current access, are urgently needed and should be a priority for future policy work.
“…Estelle vs. Gamble (1976) established that all incarcerated persons are entitled to health care for "serious medical needs;" however, adherence to professional standards for perinatal care in carceral settings (e.g., ACOG, 2021;NCCHC, 2020;Sufrin, 2018) is not monitored or enforced, resulting in varied policies, programs, and outcomes across the U.S. (Buchanan, 2012). State and federal initiatives have begun to expand support for women who are incarcerated during pregnancy (Kotlar et al, 2015;Schroeder & Bell, 2005); however services vary widely in their accessibly and provision of care (Shlafer et al, 2022;Wilson et al, 2022). Indeed, it is notable that even amongst the growing body of literature on enhanced perinatal programs in carceral settings (e.g., Wilson et al, 2022), comprehensive programs specifically targeting mental health and addiction amongst this population are rare (Steely Smith, Wilson et al, 2023a;Steely Smith et al, 2023b).…”
Background
The extraordinary growth in women’s incarceration over the past several decades has resulted in calls for expansion of research into their unique needs and experiences, including those related to pregnancy and perinatal care. However, while research into the health outcomes of women who are incarcerated while pregnant has grown, research on women’s custodial and perinatal care patterns has remained nearly non-existent. Here, we sought to describe (1) the characteristics of the population of women who came to be incarcerated in a state prison system during pregnancy and (2) the characteristics of women’s custodial and perinatal care patterns during and after incarceration.
Methods
We conducted a retrospective chart review of the population of women who received perinatal care while incarcerated in the Arkansas state prison system over a 5-year period from June 2014 to May 2019. Electronic medical records and state prison records were merged to form our study population. Data were from 212 women (Mage = 28.4 years; 75.0% non-Latina White) with a singleton pregnancy who received at least one obstetric care visit while incarcerated.
Results
Drug-related convictions were the most common crimes leading to women’s incarceration while pregnant, and violent crime convictions were rare. Nearly half (43.4%) of women who gave birth in custody did so within 90 days of admission and the great majority (80.4%) released within 1-year of giving birth, including 13.3% who released within 30 days.
Discussion
The frequency with which women who became incarcerated while pregnant released from prison either prior to or shortly after giving birth was a striking, novel finding of this study given the implications for perinatal care disruption among a high-risk population and the harms of forced separation from infants within hours of birth.
Conclusions
Diversionary programs for pregnant women convicted of crimes, particularly in states without current access, are urgently needed and should be a priority for future policy work.
“…The researchers helped inform programming in Alabama, Arkansas, Georgia, Michigan, and Virginia. The federal prison system is currently considering implementing lactation and doula care for every qualified person in federal custody [ 25 ].…”
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.