IT Human Resource Management Configurations and IT Turnover: Theoretical Synthesis and Empirical Analysis

Abstract

Increasingly, scholars and practitioners acknowledge that information technology (IT) human capital is a strategic resource and that its effective management represents a significant organizational capability. We use configurational theory to examine organizational practices related to the management of IT human capital. In contrast to much prior work in IT human resource management (HRM) that is focused at the individual level, our inquiry is focused at the organizational level of analysis. Building on strategic human resource management (SHRM) research in general and research on the management of IT professionals in particular, we examine the broad question: Are different configurations of IT HRM practices associated with different IT staff turnover rates? A multidimensional view of IT HRM practices is presented, based on prior IT and SHRM literature. We formalize hypotheses regarding the relationship of turnover with configurations of IT HRM practices grounded in prior theory and empirical research. Based on survey responses from 106 organizations, IT HRM dimensions and configurations are derived and the hypotheses are tested. A five-configuration solution, obtained via cluster analysis, includes two contrasting configurations consistent with two archetypes found in the prior literature. Specifically, the configuration with a human capital focus has lower turnover than the task-focused configuration, providing support for our first hypothesis. Although the hypothesis on intermediate configurations and their relationship with turnover is not supported, we discover and interpret three additional configurations that embody patterns of practices with unique emphases. Theoretical and practical implications of the findings are discussed.

Technology Acceptance Model, Organizational Commitment and Turnover Intention: A Conceptual Framework

“…Ferratt (2005) suggested that a task focused orientation of a human resource, focuses particularly on increasing a worker's short-term performance, and generates a higher level of turnover than configuration that focuses on the worker. When a worker's role changes after implementing information technology (Wiblen et al, 2010), she/he could be dissatisfied or even leave the job.…”

Are Foreign IT Workers Cheaper? U.S. Visa Policies and Compensation of Information Technology Professionals

“…Among high-skill workers, IT professionals who create the IT infrastructure to support critical business processes of firms (Ang and Slaughter 2000, Bartol and Aspray 2006, Ferratt et al 2005, Harter and Slaughter 2003, Josefek and Kauffman 2003) are particularly susceptible to the forces of globalization. Arguably, because many ITrelated jobs also involve high information intensity and often few requirements for physical presence, these jobs are amenable to global disaggregation and can be performed remotely or offshore (Apte and Mason 1995).…”

From Association to Causation via a Potential Outcomes Approach

“…In IS research, a wide body of academic and practitioner literature provides support for the effect of IT professionals' managerial competencies (e.g., those that can be acquired through an MBA) on career prospects. IT professionals with business knowledge play an important role in shaping the information infrastructure of a firm to help firms become agile and differentiate among their competition (Ferratt et al 2005, Josefek and Kauffman 2003, Ray et al 2005, Sambamurthy et al 2003, Smaltz et al 2006. Bharadwaj (2000) argues that managerial competencies are important in coordinating the multifaceted activities associated with successful implementation of IT systems and for the integration of IT and business planning.…”