Novel 2-alkynyl-, 4-alkynyl-, and 2,7-dialkynyl derivatives of 1,8-bis(dimethylamino)naphthalene ('proton sponge') have been synthesized and their basicity values have been measured by competitive NMR studies in DMSO. These indicate that, while the para-alkynyl groups decrease the basicity of the parent proton sponge approximately by one order of magnitude in accordance with their electron-accepting nature, the influence of ortho-alkynyl functionalities is unexpectedly base-enhancing. The latter phenomenon has been ascribed to the appearance of a buttressing effect, but some other factors can be also at work.It is commonly accepted 1 that the exceedingly high basicity (pK a = 12.1 in water 2 and 7.5 in DMSO 3 ) of 1,8-bis(dimethylamino)naphthalene (1, 'proton sponge') is mainly caused by two factors: destabilization of free base 1 by steric and electrostatic repulsion of the peri-NMe 2 groups and strong intramolecular hydrogen bonding in the protonated form 2 (Scheme 1).
Scheme 1 Protonation-deprotonation of proton sponge 1Alder's discovery 4 of proton sponges spurred interest in the area of neutral organic superbases, in particular, promoting a quest to create compounds with the highest basicity. 5 One of the early approaches to this goal consisted in placing the bulky substituents into positions ortho to the NMe 2 groups. 6 It was argued that such substituents would bring the peri-nitrogen atoms into closer proximity ('buttressing effect') making the resulting base even more destabilized and therefore stronger. Indeed, in several cases this approach turned out to be fruitful. For example, 2,7-dimethoxy derivative 3 (Figure 1) is four orders of magnitude more basic than the parent sponge 1, and naphthalene-2,7-diolate 4 so strongly holds a proton chelated between the nitrogen atoms that it cannot be removed even by metal hydrides in DMSO. 7 The basicity of 4 has been estimated to be in excess of 25 pK a units and, currently, it seems to be the most basic arylamine system. However, several years ago we demonstrated that the high basicity of 3, 4, and related compounds resulted not so much from the 'buttressing effect' as from the electrondonor nature of the methoxy and phenolate functionalities. 7,8 The most conclusive evidence in favor of this view is the relatively low basicity of 2,7-bis(trimethylsilyl) derivative 5, which tallies with the weak electron-acceptor property of the TMS group but not with its steric bulk. 8,9