Is the Boone-Indicator Applicable? – Evidence from a Combined Data Set of German Manufacturing Enterprises

Abstract

SummaryBoone (2008a) proposes a new competition measure based on Relative Profit Differences (RPD) that, from its theoretical properties, proves to be more robust than the Lerner-Index. However, the proof of the empirical practicability and robustness of the Boone-Indicator is missing. To fill this gap, we use a rich, newly built, data set for German manufacturing enterprises and test its empirical validity using cartel cases. Since all of the identified cartels significantly restricted market competition, we expect fiercer competition after the uncovering. We asses the validity of the indicators by comparing the indicated competition levels before and after the cartels were uncovered and stopped. The Boone-Indicator is calculated as RPDs and as a beta coefficient of a log-log regression. The Lerner-Index is used as a benchmark. Our analysis finds that the Boone-Indicator, based on a simple regression approach, fails to correctly indicate competition. Since the Boone-Indicator, based on pure RPDs, proves to be inapplicable, we propose an augmented indicator based on size-adjusted RPDs, which performs better. However, our findings suggest that, given the information typically available in census data, the Lerner-Index is still the only measure that correctly indicates competitive changes.

Heterogeneous monetary transmission process in the Eurozone: Does banking competition matter?

“…Second, unlike van Leuvensteijn et al (2013), we use the traditional Lerner index (Lerner, 1934) as a competition measure, which is popular in the empirical literature. Indeed, although the Boone index has a better theoretical foundation (see, e.g., Boone, 2008;Delis, 2012), the empirical robustness of this indicator remains unclear (Schiersch and Schmidt-Ehmcke, 2011). Finally, in the last part of the paper we control for the fact that rigidity in retail rates is certainly not only due to a lack of competition, but may also be due to credit risk factors and banks' risk aversion.…”

The impact of market concentration and market power on banking stability – evidence from Europe

“…We prefer the Lerner Index to the H-Statistic since Shaffer and Spierdijk (2015) expose flaws in the H-Statistic, while Schiersch and Schmidt-Ehmke (2011) highlight that the Boone Indicator suffers from empirical practicability and validity when measuring competition.…”