Economically viable
production of biobased products and
fuels requires
high-yielding, high-quality, sustainable process-advantaged crops,
developed using bioengineering or advanced breeding approaches. Understanding
which crop phenotypic traits have the largest impact on biofuel economics
and sustainability outcomes is important for the targeted feedstock
crop development. Here, we evaluated biomass yield and cell-wall composition
traits across a large natural variant population of switchgrass (Panicum virgatum L.) grown across three common garden sites.
Samples from 331 switchgrass genotypes were collected and analyzed
for carbohydrate and lignin components. Considering plant survival
and biomass after multiple years of growth, we found that 84 of the
genotypes analyzed may be suited for commercial production in the
southeastern U.S. These genotypes show a range of growth and compositional
traits across the population that are apparently independent of each
other. We used these data to conduct techno-economic analyses and
life cycle assessments evaluating the performance of each switchgrass
genotype under a standard cellulosic ethanol process model with pretreatment,
added enzymes, and fermentation. We find that switchgrass yield per
area is the largest economic driver of the minimum fuel selling price
(MSFP), ethanol yield per hectare, global warming potential (GWP),
and cumulative energy demand (CED). At any yield, the carbohydrate
content is significant but of secondary importance. Water use follows
similar trends but has more variability due to an increased dependence
on the biorefinery model. Analyses presented here highlight the primary
importance of plant yield and the secondary importance of carbohydrate
content when selecting a feedstock that is both economical and sustainable.