Investigation of the Validity and Reliability of Balance Evaluation Systems Test (BESTest) in Assessment of Balance Disorders in People With Multiple Sclerosis

Abstract

Objective Balance system and postural control are one of the major problems in people with multiple sclerosis. Therefore, the assessment of the balance system and postural control is very essential. Identification and use of standard tools can be a practical solution for more purposeful plan in this issue. Several tools have been used to investigate the balance disorders in these patients, which solely able to screen equilibrium problems, and only predict the risk of falling in the elderly. These questionnaires cannot help the therapist to diagnose the underlying causes of imbalance and also are not useful in directing the purposeful therapeutic process. The Balance Evaluation Systems Test (BESTest) was designed from 1990 to 1999 by Dr. Horak in the Continues Medical Education System. This questionnaire is based on the Bernstein's theory of motor control, and the test evaluates Biomechanical, Stability Limits, Postural Responses, Anticipatory Postural Adjustments, Sensory Orientation, and Dynamic Balance through 36 questions. The objective of this study was to determine the validity and reliability of the BESTest evaluation system in patients with multiple sclerosis after providing a coherent version of the questionnaire in Persian. Materials & Methods This is a methodological and non-experimental study. The BESTest questionnaire was translated by the researcher. The face validity of the questionnaire was evaluated by a survey of 21 patients with multiple sclerosis. The content validity of the questionnaire was further evaluated by a survey of 6 specialists in the field of rehabilitation (three occupational therapists and three specialists in the field of physiotherapy). After that, the BESTest questionnaire and Berg questionnaire were completed by two researchers (the author and another examiner) for 110 people diagnosed as multiple sclerosis, considering inclusion and exclusion criteria, from north, south, east, west, and center of Tehran in the years 2016-2017. After one week, 36 patients from the first stage were reevaluated in with a BESTest questionnaire by the researcher to evaluate the test-retest reliability. The internal consistency with Cronbach's alpha coefficient, test-retest reliability by intra-class correlation coefficients traces, inter-rater reliability coefficients of correlation between the traces, and convergent validity between the two questionnaires (BESTest and Berg) with Pearson correlation coefficient were investigated. Results The content validity of the questionnaire (the comprehensibility, relevance of the questions, and the cultural matching of words), which were measured by the CVR and CVI statistical methods, were approved by the specialist (CVI>0.79 and CVR>0.99). Pearson correlation coefficient between all the domains of the BESTest questionnaire (except for the second domain) with the score of the Berg questionnaire was between 0.79 and 0.93. Given that the numbers are above the minimum acceptable value of 0.70 indicates a good convergence between these two questionnaires. By r...

Balance in the Blind: A Systematic Review

“…he key nervous components of postural control include motor processes, such as neuromuscular synergies, and sensory processes, such as visual, vestibular, and proprioception systems [1,2]. The vestibular receivers play a significant role in basic motion responses (maintaining head and posture) as they receive input related to the position of the head in space and generating reflexes [3].…”

Comparing the Effects of Functional Electrical Stimulation With and Without Ankle-foot Orthosis on the Balance and Walking Ability of Patients With Multiple Sclerosis

“…The above statistics clearly show the importance of addressing the outcomes of MS. Because MS affects different areas of the nervous system, it can have different consequences. Destruction of the myelin sheath of nerves in any area of the brain may cause specific symptoms {Fjeldstad, 2009 #15;Kamalian Lari, 2018 #22} [6,7]. One of these debilitating symptoms is balance and gait disturbance, which interferes with moving a person from one place to another, compromising the standing balance and functional activities such as walking and activity of daily living [6][7][8].…”

“…Destruction of the myelin sheath of nerves in any area of the brain may cause specific symptoms {Fjeldstad, 2009 #15;Kamalian Lari, 2018 #22} [6,7]. One of these debilitating symptoms is balance and gait disturbance, which interferes with moving a person from one place to another, compromising the standing balance and functional activities such as walking and activity of daily living [6][7][8]. All of these factors cause patients to lose their balance and walking ability.…”

“…All of these factors cause patients to lose their balance and walking ability. Patients with MS cannot participate in society and perform social activities [6,7].…”

“…In MS, one of the most commonly involved nerves is the deep peroneal nerve, which innervates the anterior leg muscles [6,7]. These muscles are responsible for dorsiflexion and inversion of the foot.…”