Investigating the learning‐theory foundations of game‐based learning: a meta‐analysis

Abstract

Past studies on the issue of learning‐theory foundations in game‐based learning stressed the importance of establishing learning‐theory foundation and provided an exploratory examination of established learning theories. However, we found research seldom addressed the development of the use or failure to use learning‐theory foundations and categorized these learning theories into relative types and synthesized their development. We investigate this issue from the perspective of learning theories invoked to underpin educational computer game design and use based on the four types of learning theories: behaviourism, cognitivism, humanism and constructivism. Because the investigation needs to examine and analyse the results from a large number of independent previous studies, this study applied the meta‐analysis method to present a more comprehensive description and discussion of the influence and implications of the findings. This study shows the distribution of development trends for the use of learning theory as a theoretical foundation, as opposed to those that fail to use learning theory in game‐based learning, along with the distribution of types and principles of learning theories that used a learning‐theory foundation. These new findings can supplement the results of previous studies with regard to the issue of learning‐theory foundations in game‐based learning. The contributions of this study for the issue of learning‐theory foundations in game‐based learning are discussed.

Awareness Is Not Enough: Pitfalls of Learning Analytics Dashboards in the Educational Practice

“…Although other works looked into the learning theory foundations of gamebased learning [46], one major limitation of previous dashboard reviews is that none investigate the connection to learning sciences. Moreover, [35] and [4] provide recommendations for the design of learner dashboards, but none suggest the use of educational concepts as a basis for the design or evaluation of the dashboards.…”

Towards Design Patterns for Augmented Reality Serious Games

“…These theories are also the fundament for game-based learning (Wu et al, 2012), where systematic approaches towards the design of applications have already been explored with respect to delivering / providing the needed skills (Johnson et al, 2011), the motivational potential (Carstens & Beck, 2010;Douch, & Savill-Smith, 2010) as well as their ability to address various target groups in the most effective way (Unterfauner et al 2010;Liao et al 2011). …”

Constructing Knowledge in an Interactive Game-Like Design Environment for STEM Education

“…Electronic game developers have applied constructivist theory to create meaningful educational learning experiences for gamers [2]- [9]. Findings from studies of game design and the use of constructivist principles to design games yielded stronger games that had greater educational value and meaning for the players, affirming the position posited by Piaget.…”

“…Findings from studies of game design and the use of constructivist principles to design games yielded stronger games that had greater educational value and meaning for the players, affirming the position posited by Piaget. Gaming researchers examined the effective use of constructivist theory and found that game design was enhanced and learning more apparent when the theory was applied [9]- [13].…”