in the system. It is therefore gratifying that Horlick describes the ACWL as 'a remarkable success' and concludes that there is 'every reason. .. to further support and expand activities of this organization, including by pushing the United States and the EU to become Members' (page 375). Given the range of the articles in this book, both in time and subject matter, it would have been helpful to have Horlick's own view of the material, in the form of a concluding article reviewing how time has treated the topics and ideas contained in his articles. The closest thing to such an article is a piece entitled 'Nonconclusions', which was actually a summary of a different book, edited by Horlick and others, in which it first appeared. Although focusing less on trade remedies than the current book, this article nevertheless provides a concise summary of the ideas expressed by Horlick in this collection. To conclude, I would recommend this collection to any reader seeking a solid grounding in the historical background and key issues arising in the WTO over the years with respect to the subjects covered in the book, especially with respect to antidumping and subsidies.