Interactions between chromosomal and nonchromosomal elements reveal missing heritability

Abstract

The measurement of any nonchromosomal genetic contribution to the heritability of a trait is often confounded by the inability to control both the chromosomal and nonchromosomal information in a population. We have designed a unique system in yeast where we can control both sources of information so that the phenotype of a single chromosomal polymorphism can be measured in the presence of different cytoplasmic elements. With this system, we have shown that both the source of the mitochondrial genome and the presence or absence of a dsRNA virus influence the phenotype of chromosomal variants that affect the growth of yeast. Moreover, by considering this nonchromosomal information that is passed from parent to offspring and by allowing chromosomal and nonchromosomal information to exhibit nonadditive interactions, we are able to account for much of the heritability of growth traits. Taken together, our results highlight the importance of including all sources of heritable information in genetic studies and suggest a possible avenue of attack for finding additional missing heritability.A fundamental problem in genetics is unraveling the link between genotype and phenotype. Ascertaining the heritability of a trait is a key step toward harnessing the predictive capacity of genetic information for human disease risk assessment and therapy (1). Knowledge of all of the elements contributing to heritability would facilitate the establishment of a causal relationship between the information that is passed down from generation to generation and the resulting phenotype. Genomewide association studies (GWASs) have successfully identified many human polymorphisms that are associated with traits such as height, eye color, or susceptibility to common diseases, but these variants typically explain only a small proportion of the observed heritability of a trait (2, 3).A number of explanations for missing heritability have been suggested (2), including the existence of many weak variants with effects too small to achieve statistical significance (4), interactions between variants that cannot be identified with current studies (5), rare variants that were not identified by GWAS, and epigenetic effects (6-8). The contribution of nonchromosomal information to the missing heritability is rarely considered, despite the fact that there is a long history documenting the effect in many organisms of diverse cytoplasmic elements on phenotype. Recent work on a mouse model of Crohn disease supports a combinatorial model of complex disease traits in which the pathology requires the interaction between a specific mutation in the mouse and a specific strain of virus (9). Another recent study showed strong effects on the plant metabolome stemming from variation in mitochondrial and chloroplast genomes (10). In humans, the importance of nonchromosomal information has been supported by targeted analyses, but these studies have not analyzed its impact on heritability in a well-controlled context (11-13). Such nonchromosomal interactions might help e...

Higher-order genetic interactions and their contribution to complex traits

“…Although the chloroplast and mitochondria are the most frequently studied cytoplasmic factors, plasmids, prions, and viruses can also have heritable phenotypic effects [40, 41]. Work on a number of species has shown that cytonuclear interactions are pervasive [39] and can significantly influence complex traits, such as longevity in flies [42], flowering time, growth, and defense against herbivores and pathogens in plants [43, 44], and the growth effects of gene deletions in yeast [40]. A recent study on heritable variation in metabolism in an Arabidopsis cross is particularly relevant to the discussion of HGIs [45].…”

Unisexual versus bisexual mating in Cryptococcus neoformans: Consequences and biological impacts

“…Recent work in S. cerevisiae suggests sex can result in advantageous selection independent of genomic diversity, but instead by transmission of cytoplasmic elements, like dsRNA viruses (Edwards et al, 2014) or prions (Suzuki et al, 2012). Interspecies mating may cross species barriers, and usually results in abortive mating, yet cytoplasmic elements are able to be transmitted between the mating pairs.…”

A population study of killer viruses reveals different evolutionary histories of two closely related Saccharomyces sensu stricto yeasts

“…Indeed, a recent finding that the presence of dsRNA viruses changes the expression of host phenotypes associated with six nuclear deletion mutations (Edwards et al . ) suggests that viruses may influence the strength of selection acting on host genes. Furthermore, a recent phylogenetic analysis showed that two families of mycoviruses codiverge with their hosts (Goker et al .…”