Inter- and Intra-Scorer Rorschach Reliability

Voigt, Walter H.; Dana, Richard H.

doi:10.1080/0091651x.1964.10120099

Cited by 7 publications

(3 citation statements)

References 5 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…Nonetheless, the mean estimate of absolute agreement (66.7%) does compare favorably with figures reported elsewhere (e.g., Voigt & Dana, 1964). Nonetheless, the mean estimate of absolute agreement (66.7%) does compare favorably with figures reported elsewhere (e.g., Voigt & Dana, 1964).…”

Section: Discussionsupporting

confidence: 59%

Peebles' Rorschach Content Scoring System: Reliability, Normative Data, and Validity

Murphy

Dana

1969

Journal of Projective Techniques and Personality Assessment

Self Cite

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

This study reports normative data for the Peebles Rorschach content scoring system. Group Rorschach protocols from undergraduates were scored and reliably classified by quadrant. Frequencies were obtained by sex and by quadrant. Social desirability was demonstrated to vary across quadrants. The validity of quadrant classification was suggested by self-reports and MMPI scales. MMPI profile code predictions were made by experts for each quadrant and compared with obtained mean profile codes. The scoring system was evaluated and theoretical origins were discussed.

show abstract

Section: Discussionsupporting

confidence: 59%

Peebles' Rorschach Content Scoring System: Reliability, Normative Data, and Validity

Murphy

Dana

1969

Journal of Projective Techniques and Personality Assessment

Self Cite

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Two problems presented themselves in this context. First, interscorer reliabilities for the Rorschach as a whole tend to be only moderately high, ranging from 69 to 86 percent agreement (Voigt & Dana, 1964). Second, Rorschach experts differ on what should and should not be scored for movement.…”

Section: Hypothesis I: Changes In Quantity Of Movement During Dream D...mentioning

confidence: 99%

Rorschach movement and dreams: A validation study using drug-induced dream-deprivation.

Lerner¹

1966

Journal of Abnormal Psychology

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

To test the hypotheses that dream deprivation would produce an increase in quantity of projected movement and a change in its quality in the direction of body-dissolution imagery, 20 Ss were tested with Holtzman inkblots before and after 2 nights of drug-induced dream deprivation. Their performance was compared with that of 30 non-dream-deprived controls. Results were significant in the predicted direction and were interpreted as offering support for Rorschach's views on the fundamental similarity between movement and dreams due to the centrality of kinesthetic experience in both. Additional findings on space were congruent with Fonda's view of space as resistance to internal, rather than external, forces. More specifically, in the present study, space was interpreted as resistance to movement.

show abstract

“…Low in ter scorer an d in trascorer co nsisten cy on Rorscha ch scoring is still a problem (224). Wh ile su ch unreli abi li ty ca n almost alway s be redu ced to a negligible lev el by intensive tr ai ning, it makes su ch a free-response te ch nique highly expensive.…”

Section: Conceptual-operational Coordination and Validation Of Measuresmentioning

confidence: 99%

Theory and Techniques of Personality Measurement

Fiske¹,

Pearson²

1970

Annu. Rev. Psychol.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

This chapter is one of the intermittent series which has had "assess ment" in its title. The authors have dropped that term because of its impre cision and its connotations. Assessment has often been used to refer to the combining of measures, usually by human judgment, to predict a criterion. But personality measurement as a whole involves the combination or reduc tion of observations to obtain an index and is concerned with much more than the prediction of criteria. Additionally, the terms assessment and crite ria have an evaluative flavor; while adequacy of functioning is involved in much of personality, a science of personality must not be limited to norma tive considerations. Finally, assessment has the connotation of dealing with the whole person. It seems quite clear that we cannot have a science of the whole person, or even of substantial segments of personality, until we un derstand the components.Most concepts in the personality field are so broad and heterogeneous in their referents that when one concept is used to describe different persons, it is very doubtful that the identical attribute is applied to each. The task fac ing personality today is the identifi cation and delineation of attributes which can be uniformly applied to persons, the objects of this science, with the specifi c applications of each attribute differing only in quantity, not quality. Coordinate with that task is the work of developing operations for measur ing each of these attributes. Such procedures must be standardized so that the measurements can, in principle, be replicated for the same persons and, particularly critical in this area, so that the measurements are getting at the same attribute in the different persons measured, without any sizable per son-instrument interaction. This chapter is concerned with the extent to which these standards are being approximated in personality measurement today.A science develops by an interactive or cyclical process, observations leading to concepts, and concepts guiding the next set of observations. In personality, an infi nity of observations has been conceptualized in a variety of sets of terms with general statements about them. These literary or even

show abstract

Inter- and Intra-Scorer Rorschach Reliability

Cited by 7 publications

References 5 publications

Peebles' Rorschach Content Scoring System: Reliability, Normative Data, and Validity

Peebles' Rorschach Content Scoring System: Reliability, Normative Data, and Validity

Rorschach movement and dreams: A validation study using drug-induced dream-deprivation.

Theory and Techniques of Personality Measurement

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About