Intentionally flawed manuscripts as means for teaching students to critically evaluate scientific papers

Abstract

As future scientists, university students need to learn how to avoid making errors in their own manuscripts, as well as how to identify flaws in papers published by their peers. Here we describe a novel approach on how to promote students' ability to critically evaluate scientific articles. The exercise is based on instructing teams of students to write intentionally flawed manuscripts describing the results of simple experiments. The teams are supervised by instructors advising the students during manuscript writing, choosing the 'appropriate' errors, monitoring the identification of errors made by the other team and evaluating the strength of their arguments in support of the identified errors. We have compared the effectiveness of the method with a journal club-type seminar. Based on the results of our assessment we propose that the described seminar may effectively complement the existing approaches to teach critical scientific thinking.

A low‐cost cure for CUREs: An undergraduate microbiology course engaging students in authentic research using publicly available datasets

“…In the absence of publicly available data, instructors can implement a project‐based research course at low‐cost by utilizing datasets that have previously been generated in the instructor's research group 14,31 . In this case, students would choose their project topics from a subset of questions that directly relate to the faculty member's area of research.…”

“…30 In the absence of publicly available data, instructors can implement a project-based research course at lowcost by utilizing datasets that have previously been generated in the instructor's research group. 14,31 In this case, students would choose their project topics from a subset of questions that directly relate to the faculty member's area of research. If the faculty member is teaching a course with a larger number of students, the course capacity could be increased through the use of teaching assistants, and it may be especially helpful if they were graduate students in the faculty member's research group.…”

Developing Students’ Skills of Identifying Reliable Scientific Sources: The Role of a Librarian

“…Once the real matter of things becomes clear students are being taught skills of how to deal with scientific information. Along with traditional platforms of seminars and learning courses there might be unconventional forms of journalistic clubs [9] or activities on evaluation of articles containing deliberate mistakes [11].…”

Developing Students' Skills of Identifying Reliable Scientific Sources: How to Avoid Fake Information

“…Once the real matter of things becomes clear students are being taught skills of how to deal with scientific information. Along with traditional platforms of seminars and learning courses there might be unconventional forms of journalistic clubs (Esisi, 2007) or activities on evaluation of articles containing deliberate mistakes (Ferenc et al, 2018).…”