Integrating Visualization into Structured Public Involvement: Case Study of Highway Improvement in Central Kentucky

Abstract

Public involvement in transportation infrastructure decision making is frequently mandated and is regarded as increasingly essential by a wide variety of stakeholders. The integration of advanced technologies, such as visualization, into this process is increasingly desired. However, public involvement processes often are regarded as problematic by many stakeholders and the state highway agencies charged with implementing them. Structured public involvement (SPI) is posited. SPI takes a systems approach toward the integration of advanced technologies into public involvement forums. Because the goal of public involvement is to increase user satisfaction with both the process and the outcomes, the characteristics of advanced technologies and their capacities for gathering useful feedback in public forums must be evaluated. Visualization is put forth as an enabling technology within an SPI framework. The properties, capacities, and transportation-related uses of three visualization modes are evaluated, and their operational features are discussed. A case study dealing with highway improvement in central Kentucky reveals that three-dimensional renderings are significantly preferred to twodimensional and virtual reality modes; the case study also shows that visualization should complement, not replace, other performance information. The role of electronic scoring as an integral component of this SPI protocol is emphasized, resulting in fast assessment and free expression of views. Factors affecting the efficiency of visualization are analyzed, and recommendations are presented for implementing SPI protocols that rely on visualization. These include investigating participants' previous experience with visualization, incorporating iterative public involvement in finalizing design options, and ensuring that the technologies are compatible with the chosen public involvement process.

Highway Alignment Optimization: An Integrated BIM and GIS Approach

“…In [14], a model was developed for the highway to display properties of alternative solutions. The findings of study [15] also demonstrated that 3D modelling with corresponding analysis can improve significantly the performance of highway improvement. According to the results of study [16], the 3D visualization of the proposed project can increase users' understanding and help them obtain detailed information about the project and its context.…”

Participatory GIS as a Tool for Stakeholder Engagement in Building Resilience to Sea Level Rise: A Demonstration Project

“…The ASERT framework emphasizes the presentation of relevant and accessible information, coupled with the use of two-way communication and deliberative and participatory mechanisms. The deliberative and participatory components of the ASERT framework build on the Structured Public Involvement approach that has been applied in high-conflict decision-making contexts such as environmental and transportation planning (Bailey et al, 2002(Bailey et al, , 2007(Bailey et al, , 2011.…”

Ferry Parking and Landside Access Study

“…This feedback allows planner to accurately assess the level of understanding the public has on a particular project. A positive signal occurs when the public begins to supply useful and insightful comments regarding a proposed activity (8).…”