Insights into Teacher Beliefs and Practice in Primary-School EFL in France

Abstract

Teacher beliefs affect choices of methods, representations of learning, and classroom practice, and are important in understanding primary EFL teaching in France, where language teaching has been a compulsory subject entrusted to generalist class teachers for 20 years. This quantitative study explores questionnaire data from 254 primary teachers, associating teacher beliefs and classroom practice. With respect to views of language teaching and learning, the study reveals a three-way division of teachers between grammar-oriented teaching (PPP), communicative-language teaching (CLT), and ‘sceptical’ teachers. The PPP (n = 72) group employed the smallest range of teaching activities and rarely taught older pupils. The CLT group (n = 60) tended to have higher English proficiency and more in-service training and offered the widest range of oral activities. The sceptical group (n = 85) took no strong theoretical position, had lower English proficiency, and focused on listening and speaking skills. We found no correlation between teacher age and language learning beliefs or teaching practices. However, teachers who offered a wider range of activities in any of the five competences tended to have more in-service training and higher English proficiency. Further correlations were found between oral language teaching and technology integration, and written language teaching and teaching experience. The paper concludes with links to previous teacher cognition research and suggestions for teacher education.

Enseñar historia en México: percepciones docentes en la Educación Primaria

“…El trabajo que realizan los profesores en sus aulas, junto con su formación inicial, les permite adquirir ciertas percepciones y concepciones sobre la forma de enseñar las asignaturas y sobre cómo debe ser su práctica educativa para beneficio de los estudiantes. Las concepciones forman parte de la estructura del pensamiento docente, que conlleva creencias, significados, conceptos y reglas; toda una construcción subjetiva, elaborada a lo largo de la vida, que termina condicionando su práctica docente (Whyte et al, 2022).…”

“The Nail That Sticks Out Gets Hammered down”: The Influence Of EFL Context On The Teacher Beliefs Of A Native English-Speaking Teacher

“…A considerable amount of research spanning the past three decades has confirmed that teachers' classroom practices are substantially affected by what they think, do, believe, and teacher beliefs are shaped by their past learning and teaching experiences (Borg, 2003;Clark & Peterson, 1984;Golombek, 1998;Kagan, 1992;Pajares, 1992;Whyte et al, 2022). Everything teachers do in a classroom is influenced by their beliefs and teachers practice in line with their beliefs (Williams & Burden, 1997).…”

“…However, some studies have found an incongruence between what teachers think and believe and what they actually do in the classroom. In other words, practice does not always match stated beliefs (Mercer, 2018;Whyte et al, 2022). The methods used to elicit teachers' beliefs might be responsible for the inconsistency between stated beliefs and enacted beliefs (Fives & Buehl, 2012).…”

Language Practices in English Classrooms: Guest Editors’ Introduction to the Special Issue

“…In France, EFL teaching has been a compulsory subject taught by primary school class teachers for two decades. Whyte et al (2022) examined questionnaire data from teachers (N = 254), connecting participants' beliefs and reported practices. The study revealed a three-part division of teachers and teaching that could be tied to grammar-oriented teaching, communicative-language teaching, and teachers who were described as skeptical.…”