Innocents Abroad: Western Fantasies of Childhood and the Iconography of Emergencies

Abstract

In this paper I explore the emotional interests maintained by the imagery of children used in Third World emergencies. Boundaries between adult and child are reproduced through relations of paternalism between North and South, such that the infantilisation of the South exemplified in imagery of children works to secure the competence and maturity of the Northern donor. Drawing on both analyses of the cultural origins and meanings of concepts of childhood and psychoanalytic perspectives, I suggest that media coverage of disasters arouses both identification and strategies to ward off and protect from the anxiety this brings. The gendered as well as geographical distribution of qualities of children's innocence and experience are discussed, drawing on both general imagery of children and recent coverage of children and child-saving, particularly in the former Yugoslavia. Developing analyses of 'disaster pornography', the paper explores how children appear as the principal focal objects onto which attention is pinned and as the signifiers of distress. This is at the cost of dehumanizing both children, their families and their cultures, and rendering them passive objects of a western gaze which seeks to confirm its own agency and omnipotence to ward off its own insecurities. While aid organisations and campaigns necessarily engage with, and sometimes collude with, these reactions, the paper ends by suggesting that there may be strategies whereby images of children can function to comment on rather than maintain prevailing colonial and paternalistic relations.

Walter Benjamin’s Dionysian Adventures on Google Earth

“…On the one hand, we could affirm the project because of its aims to educate a broad audience about the geographical context of the crisis. On the other hand, we could decry the project's complicity in ''disaster pornography" (Burman, 1994) to the extent that its mode of educating is fraught with the voyeuristic pleasure of examining yet more disasters, terrors, and destruction in Africa or other parts of the Global South. We are sympathetic to both of these readings but are weary of how they fall in line with Apollonian either/or logic.…”

‘They don’t look like children’: child asylum-seekers, the Dubs amendment and the politics of childhood

“…7. From the imploring eyes of the Rwandan child that Agamben (1998, 33) invokes, to the children that dominated the media coverage of the Balkans war (see Burman 1994) or the Iraq war in 2003 (see Holland 2004b). Children, of course, have also featured heavily in the media coverage of the ongoing conflict in Syria.…”

Towards a Working Definition and Application of Social Age in International Development Studies

“…Scholars argue that it creates an arbitrary dividing line -one's eighteenth birthday -between childhood and adulthood (Cohen, 1980;Freeman, 1983;Ladd, 2002;Rogers, 2003). Moreover, it reflects primarily western legal traditions and traditional psychological development discourses that imply universal and monolithic qualities of childhood and youth (Burman, 1994;Boyden, 1997;Pupavac, 2001;White, 2002). In reality, the experiences of children and young people vary widely in relation to social, political and environmental conditions, and individual characteristics (Kessen, 1981;Ingleby, 1986;Scheper-Hughes and Sargent, 1998).…”