Reconstituted skim milk powder (RSMP) was fortified with 12.5 mM/L calcium (Ca) using soluble [Ca chloride (CChlor), Ca gluconate (CGluc) or Ca hydroxide (CHyd)] or insoluble [Ca carbonate (CCarb), Ca phosphate (CPhos) or Ca citrate (CCit)] salts. CPhos and CCit decreased heat stability moderately at 140 °C, while CCarb had no effect. Soluble salts had a pronounced destabilising effect at 140 °C due to increased ionic Ca levels. After a laboratory‐scale high‐temperature short‐time heating process, CHyd‐fortified RSMP had a lower viscosity than all other samples. CChlor and CGluc increased sedimentation during accelerated physical stability testing, with CHyd causing greater sedimentation than CChlor or CGluc.