Inferring competence from incompetence: An ironic process associated with person descriptors

Abstract

To what extent is a competently-functioningperson also interested in the person descriptors associated with that competence? A thesis by Wicklund (1986a, b ) charges that a dwelling on static person qualities (overt appearance; superficial traits) is often to be found among individuals who are themselves incompetent in the performance area in question: several studies in recent years have supported this thesis, and one of these provides the basis of the present work: Wicklund, Braun and Waibel (1993) found that athletes, scientists, farmers and other groups were disinclined to characterize their performance areas in terms of the static traits of the expert. In sharp contrast. respondents who were relatively non-skilled in aperformance area ( 'distant 'area) were rnclined to depict the area in terms of static elements, such as overt appearance and traits.Each of the present subjects received two protocols from one of these previous subjects (above). In one protocol the earlier subject had depicted his own area (and thereby mentioned, on the average, relatively few static person descriptors); in the other protocol he depicted a 'distant' performance area (and usually made reference to one or more person descriptors). The present subjects' task was to infer the original subjects' competence in those two areas, and given that our subjects were inactive in both areas, they came systematically to the incorrect conclusion: they reacted to protocols laden with person descrytors as signalling the author's actual competence, a phenomenon consistent with the descriptions of technical societies in Sennett (1977) Subjects who evidenced some degree of competence in the pertinent areas did not commit this error Addressee for correspondence: Robert A. Wicklund. Abteilung fur Psychologie, Universitit Bielefeld, 33501 Bielefeld, Germany. We would like to acknowledge support from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft for grants (Wi 79512-4 and Wi 79514-1) that supported the present research.

How Entrepreneurs Use Symbolic Management to Acquire Resources

“…The symbolic action of displaying the degree from a prestigious business school increased the confidence of the resource holder in the entrepreneurs' competence. Waibel and Wicklund (1994) have found that people who are unable to assess the actual performance of another person tend to rely on displays of personal attributes to make inferences about the person's level of competence (e.g., successful artists have long hair, MBA graduates from a certain school are competent business people), even if these stereotypes have little bearing on actual abilities.…”

Quality of Life: A Deconstruction for Clinicians

“…With regard to negative affect, bad mood can cause bodily symptoms 19,26,27 , but under certain conditions the reverse can also be true 28 . Similarly incompetence can lead to selfrelated thinking [29][30][31] , but individuals are perceived as competent by outside observers when they use self-related terms in describing an activity 32 . Many phenomena investigated in social psychology have bidirectional, dynamic, causal relationships 33 .…”

Revitalizing Entrepreneurship: How Visual Symbols are Used in Entrepreneurial Performances

“…Both serial entrepreneurs (Sorby Properties and Coupland Technologies) routinely used business dress while the founder of XYZ Software was less consistent in this activity as outlined further in the next section. Waibel and Wicklund (1994) have found that people who are unable to assess the actual performance of another tend to rely on displays of personal attributes to make inferences about the person's level of competence (overt appearance, superficial traits), even if these stereotypes have little bearing on actual abilities. Therefore presenting appearances that are ‘visually salient’ could potentially assist entrepreneurs in securing the resources they need.…”