Increasing Uptake of Depression Screening and Treatment Guidelines in Cardiac Patients: A Behavioral and Implementation Science Approach to Developing a Theory-Informed, Multilevel Implementation Strategy

Abstract

Background: Depression leads to poor health outcomes in patients with coronary heart disease (CHD). Despite guidelines recommending screening and treatment of depressed patients with CHD, few patients receive optimal care. We applied behavioral and implementation science methods to (1) identify generalizable, multilevel barriers to depression screening and treatment in patients with CHD and (2) develop a theory-informed, multilevel implementation strategy for promoting guideline adoption. Methods: We conducted a narrative review of barriers to depression screening and treatment in patients with CHD (ie, medications, exercise, cardiac rehabilitation, or therapy) comprising data from 748 study participants. Informed by the behavior change wheel framework and Expert Recommendations for Implementing Change, we defined multilevel target behaviors, characterized determinants (capability, opportunity, motivation), and mapped barriers to feasible, acceptable, and equitable intervention functions and behavior change techniques to develop a multilevel implementation strategy, targeting health care systems/providers and patients. Results: We identified implementation barriers at the system/provider level (eg, Capability: knowledge; Opportunity: workflow integration; Motivation: ownership) and patient level (eg, Capability: knowledge; Opportunity: mobility; Motivation: symptom denial). Acceptable, feasible, and equitable intervention functions included education, persuasion, environmental restructuring, and enablement. Expert Recommendations for Implementing Change strategies included learning collaborative, audit, feedback, and educational materials. The final multicomponent strategy (iHeart DepCare) for promoting depression screening/treatment included problem-solving meetings with clinic staff (system); educational/motivational videos, electronic health record reminders/decisional support (provider); and a shared decision-making (electronic shared decision-making) tool with several functions for patients, for example, patient activation, patient treatment selection support. Conclusions: We applied implementation and behavioral science methods to identify implementation barriers and to develop a multilevel implementation strategy for increasing uptake of depression screening and treatment in patients with CHD as a use case. The multilevel implementation strategy will be evaluated in a future hybrid II effectiveness-implementation trial.

Comparison of analog and digital patient decision aids for the treatment of depression: a scoping review

“…Furthermore, some studies pointed out that the use of PDAs in SDM did not increase the consultation time ( 25 , 46 , 49 , 62 , 63 ). Finally, an inclusion of personal stories was considered to be beneficial for patients' elicitation of their preferences because they could relate to people with similar experiences ( 48 , 59 , 68 ).…”

Brief trauma-informed care training to enhance health care providers’ knowledge, comfort, and implementation of trauma-informed care in primary care clinics: A pilot effectiveness study.

“…It is likely that interconnected layers of support are needed for TIC implementation to be effective. At the individual patient level, motivation and buy-in by the provider are needed and this requires provider knowledge and comfort (Huo et al, 2023; Reuter et al, 2022). While a brief training like the one administered in this pilot study was particularly useful at increasing knowledge, offering hands-on trainings such as simulated patient encounters and/or longitudinal coaching to increase providers’ comfort with use of TIC may help in supporting consistent implementation of TIC.…”

Human Factors and Organizational Issues: Contributions from 2022

“…Implementation is a central consideration [1,2]. The focus may be individuals in good health looking to stay healthy [2] or to maintain motivation towards healthy behaviors [3], or people living with an acute or chronic condition [4,5]. In age, the subjects range from the unborn [6] to those in decline through ageing.…”