Incorporating Uncertainty into the Estimation of the Passing Sight Distance Requirements

Abstract

Passing sight distance (PSD) is provided to ensure the safety of passing maneuvers on two lane two way roads. Many random variables determine the minimum length required for a safe passing maneuver. Current PSD design practices replace these random variables by single-value means in the calculation process, disregarding their inherent variations, which results in a single-value PSD design criteria. The main objective of the article is to derive a PSD distribution that accounts for the variations in the contributing random variables. Two models are devised, a Monte-Carlo simulation model used to obtain the PSD distribution and a closed form analytical estimation model used for verification purposes. The Monte-Carlo simulation model uses random sampling to select the values of the contributing parameters from their corresponding distributions in each run. The analytical model accounts for each parameter variation by using their means and standard deviations in a closed form estimation method. The means and standard deviations of the PSD using both models are compared for verification purposes. Both models use the same PSD formulation. The analysis is conducted for a design speed of 80 Km/h (50 mph). A PSD distribution is developed accordingly. The results of both models differ only by less than 2%. The obtained distribution is used to estimate the reliability index

TSVC: timed efficient and secure vehicular communications with privacy preserving

“…On the highway, drivers must observe the speed restrictions; however, there are still a few overspeeding vehicles and low speed vehicles. Khoury et al in [19] used the FHWA(Federal Highway Administration) Highway Statistics 2002, and applied the MonteCarlo simulation model as well as a closed form analytical estimation model to demonstrate that the vehicle speed on the highways fit into a truncated Gaussian distribution. Thus, the probability that A enters the O's virtual cell in test time T is denoted as P (l − R < (v − v 0 )T |v), and can be expressed as:…”

Performance-Based Analysis in Civil Engineering: Overview of Applications

“…Various applications related to geometric design and traffic operations [20][21][22][23][24][25][26][27][28][29][30][31][32][33][34] are found in Table A1. The applications rely mostly on the geometric design guides by AASHTO [35] and the Transportation Association of Canada (TAC) [36].…”

“…El-Khoury and Hobeika [23] applied MC simulation to estimate the uncertainty level contained in passing sight distance (PSD) requirements on straight roadway segments. A reliability-based design method was developed to estimate the uncertainty of the three-dimensional (3D) SD boundaries on horizontal alignments that overlap with flat grades, crest curves, and sag curves [24].…”

Analytical Model for Passing Sight Distance Design Criteria of Two-Lane Roads in Sri Lanka

“…However, the reliability of proposed model and AASHTO model was needed to assess to decide which model is safer under actual demand. Following safety index method in equation 13 was introduced by Cornell in 1969, to compare network reliability under actual demand distribution (Khoury and Hobeika, 2007). Table 4 shows calculated indices for two models and actual demand.…”