Income and Well-Being: Relative Income and Absolute Income Weaken Negative Emotion, but Only Relative Income Improves Positive Emotion

Abstract

Whether relative income or absolute income could affect subjective well-being has been a bone of contention for years. Life satisfaction and the relative frequency of positive and negative emotions are parts of subjective well-being. According to the prospect theory, hedonic adaptation helps to explain why positive emotion is often so hard to be maintained, and negative emotion wouldn’t be easy to be eliminated. So we expect the relationship between income and positive emotion is different from that between income and negative emotion. Given that regional reference is the main comparison mechanism, effects of regional average income on regional average subjective well-being should be potentially zero if only relative income matters. Using multilevel analysis, we tested the hypotheses with a dataset of 30,144 individuals from 162 counties in China. The results suggested that household income at the individual level is associated with life satisfaction, happiness and negative emotions. On the contrary, at a county level, household income is only associated with negative emotion. In other words, happiness and life satisfaction was only associated with relative income, but negative emotion was associated with relative income and absolute income. Without social comparison, income doesn’t improve happiness, but it could weaken negative emotion. Therefore, it is possible for economic growth to weaken negative emotion without improving happiness. These findings also contribute to the current debate about the “Esterling paradox.”

Sociodemographic Factors’ Association with Community-Dwelling Older Adults’ Psychosocial Wellbeing: The Greek Context

“…Our results confirmed that higher monthly income was related to better outcomes on all psychosocial outcome measures. This finding substantiates the anticipated close relationship between psychological wellbeing and poverty, consistent with the findings of previous studies (Arendt, 2005;Camfield & Esposito, 2014;Yu & Chen, 2016), indicating that higher income could help people overcome difficult circumstances including hunger and cold that may negatively affect their subjective wellbeing. Moreover, money leads to increased happiness if it can be exchanged for goods that will improve an individual's utility and general social rank (Boyce, Brown, & Moore, 2010).…”

Economic Cognitions Among Older Adults: Parental Socialization Predicts Financial Planning for Retirement

“…In the same vein, future research would consider that parental economic socialization should interact with emotions or other individual features (Rodríguez et al, 2015 ; Yu and Chen, 2016 ) or personality characteristics (Topa and Herrador-Alcaide, 2016 ) in order to affect retirement planning.…”

Hope Mediates the Relation between Income and Subjective Well-Being

“…Income most likely affects how we perceive our global life circumstances as it is something that we often consider when judging how our overall life is going, while its impact on what we experience on a daily basis may be more limited, especially if we take hedonic adaptation into account, i.e. the human tendency to easily get used to new situations and standards of living (Yu and Chen 2016). Moreover, income can be assumed to increase life's comforts and to help us fulfil our desires, but may be less efficient in fulfilling our fundamental psychological needs such as connectedness, autonomy and competence, whereas the latter has been found to be more closely related to emotional wellbeing (Scitovsky 1978;Diener et al 2010).…”