“…Note that, for such conditions, both thresholds are approximately equivalent to each other and Θ t (Clark et al., 2017; Pähtz & Durán, 2018a). Furthermore, flume measurements of the visual initiation threshold for subaqueous bedload by Karahan (1975, K75, s ≃ 2.65), Fernandez Luque and van Beek (1976, FLB76, s ∈ (1.3, 4.6)), and Yalin and Karahan (1979, YK79t, s ≃ 2.65) are shown (closed symbols in Figure 5c), where critical conditions are defined by a critical value of a proxy characterizing the state of transport, such as a critical value of the nondimensionalized bed sediment entrainment rate (Paphitis, 2001, Equation 7). It has been argued that the resulting threshold is close to Θ t because such and similar critical transport conditions are associated with an abrupt sharp transition in the behavior of Q * as a function of Θ (Pähtz et al., 2020).…”