Improving Packet Delivery Performance of Publish/Subscribe Protocols in Wireless Sensor Networks

Abstract

MQTT-S and CoAP are two protocols able to use the publish/subscribe model in Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs). The high scalability provided by the publish/subscribe model may incur a high packet loss and therefore requires an efficient reliability mechanism to cope with this situation. The reliability mechanism of MQTT-S and CoAP employs a method which defines a fixed value for the retransmission timeout (RTO). This article argues that this method is not efficient for deploying publish/subscribe in WSN, because it may be unable to recover a packet, therefore resulting in a lower packet delivery ratio (PDR) at the subscriber nodes. This article proposes and evaluates an adaptive RTO method, which consists in using a Smooth Round-trip Time and multiplying it by a constant parameter (K). Thanks to this method, the reliability mechanism of MQTT-S and CoAP would be able to react properly to packet loss and would also be lightweight in terms of energy, memory and computing for sensor nodes where these resources are critical. We present a detailed evaluation of the effects of the K value on the calculation of the adaptive RTO method. We also establish the setting for obtaining the highest PDR on the subscriber nodes for single-hop and multi-hop scenarios. The results for single-hop scenario show that use of the appropriate K value for the adaptive RTO method increases the PDR up to 76% for MQTT-S and up to 38% for CoAP when compared with the use of fixed RTO method for both protocols, respectively. Meanwhile the same comparison for multi-hop scenario, the adaptive RTO method increases the PDR up to 36% for MQTT-S and up to 14% for CoAP.

Application-derived communication protocol selection in M2M platforms for smart cities

“…The comparison between dierent M2M/IoT protocols has been a subject of discussions in recent literature work [100,101,94]. Table 3.5 presents a comparison of the M2M transport protocols reviewed in previous subsections.…”

Handling mobility in IoT applications using the MQTT protocol

“…In [9] authors present a study of the reliability mechanism used by the MQTT-S and CoAP protocols. The authors demonstrate that both protocols would achieve a better performance by modifying the Retransmission Time Out (RTO) calculation method from a fixed to an adaptative value.…”

Composite Metric Based Energy Efficient Routing Protocol for Internet of Things

“…Or otherwise the ratio of data packets successfully received to the total sent. X Axis indicates transmission speed (RX) and Y Axis indicates Packet delivery ratio [26]. The transmit ratio(TX) is 100% and receive ratio (RX) is different values are given and tested.…”