Impact of Kinetic Models on Methanol Synthesis Reactor Predictions: In Silico Assessment and Comparison with Industrial Data

Abstract

The reactor is one of the most important equipment to be designed for optimal process operations. An appropriate reactor modeling leads to an efficient and optimal process conceptual design, simulation, and eventually construction. The key for success in this step is mainly related to kinetics. The present work is centered toward process simulation and aims at comparing three different kinetic models for methanol synthesis. The comparison shows how the refitted Graaf model, presented in a previous study, effectively predicts the performance of modern methanol synthesis loops. To pursue this objective, we simulated in Aspen HYSYS three methanol synthesis technologies (the most popular technologies in modern plants) and compared the results with industrial data. The proposed case study demonstrates that the refitted Graaf model is more accurate in output prediction than the wellestablished original Graaf and Vanden Bussche−Froment models, which are currently considered the industrial benchmark, thus showing how the refitted Graaf model is a potential candidate for future industrial applications.

Design and Simulation of a Plastic Waste to Methanol Process: Yields and Economics

“…Methanol synthesis is an exothermic reaction with a copper based catalyst which is sensitive to deactivation at relatively low temperature, so very good care is given to heat transfer. Kinetics in this section is modeled using the refitted Graaf model developed by Bisotti et al The reactor effluent is used to preheat the feed and then cooled with air to be finally condensed in a water-cooled exchanger. The crude methanol–water mixture is collected in a vessel, while the remaining syngas is sent to a compressor to recover pressure drops.…”

“…It is primarily produced from methane and coal and considered a key molecule of the energy transition . CO 2 hydrogenation to methanol in particular is considered a promising pathway for carbon utilization …”

Plastic Waste Chemical Recycling to Methanol: Combined Experimental and Plant-Wide Simulated Approach

“…The pre-reforming unit is followed by a primary steam methane reformer (H101 in Figure ) operating at a pressure of 9 bar with a H 2 O/CH 4 ratio of 4. The unit implements the Xu-Froment kinetic model for its computations that was developed on Ni-Alumina Catalyst . The low pressure and high H 2 O/CH 4 ratio are chosen to achieve a methane conversion across the unit that is higher than 90%.…”

“…The unit implements the Xu-Froment 23 kinetic model for its computations that was developed on Ni-Alumina Catalyst. 24 The low pressure and high H 2 O/CH 4 ratio are chosen to achieve a methane conversion across the unit that is higher than 90%. This conversion is made more complex to achieve by the presence of hydrogen and carbon monoxide in the feed of the reformer.…”

A versatile modular plant for converting biogas into advanced biofuels

“…The difference lies in heat management, this led to a different strategy in the cooling operations. The unit was modelled as a HYSYS plug flow reactor with refitted Graaf's heterogeneous kinetic model, proposed in the work of Bisotti et al (2022) [4]. The hot products, rich in methanol and unconverted syngas, were cooled with (i) process-process heat exchanger, (ii) air cooler, and (iii) cooling water heat exchanger.…”