Illness Perceptions and Quality of Life in Japanese and Dutch Women with Breast Cancer

Abstract

Knowledge on cross-cultural quality of life (QOL) and illness perceptions may help women with breast cancer cope more effectively. The self regulation model (SRM) guided the current exploratory longitudinal pilot-study. Central to SRM is the perception of health threats and their effects on QOL. Illness perceptions and QOL were assessed in 22 Dutch and 21 Japanese patients with breast cancer who filled out questionnaires before, 1 week, and 8 weeks after the first chemotherapy course. The questionnaires assessed QOL and illness perceptions. Patients' scores were compared with groups of patients with other chronic somatic illnesses (asthma, diabetes). Patients in both samples reported major impact of chemotherapy on global health status, physical functioning, role functioning, emotional functioning, constipation and diarrhea. Differences between Japanese and Dutch patients were limited to social functioning and financial problems. Japanese patients expressed stronger concerns about their illness than Dutch patients. Results of the Japanese and Dutch patients with breast cancer differed from data in patients with asthma on consequences, timeline, concern and emotional response. Results of Japanese patients differed from patients with type 2 diabetes on timeline and concern, whereas Dutch patients differed on timeline and consequences. Japanese and Dutch breast cancer patients have-overall-similar illness perceptions and QOL responses and are aware of the typical characteristics of their disease. The results support the feasibility of cross-cultural psychosocial research in oncology and offer implications for clinical interventions which impact on self-efficacy to empower patients with breast cancer.

Speech pathology services for people with aphasia: what is the current practice in Singapore?

“…The perceived lack of need of aphasia services seems to stem from more deeply rooted cultural beliefs about age and communication. This is not entirely surprising as cross-cultural differences have been found in perceptions toward communication problems such as voice disorders [71] as well as perceptions of illness [72], recovery [73] and long-term care [74]. In addition, age and culture have been found to influence illness perceptions and adherence to prescribed treatment regimes [75].…”

Cognitive and functional impairment, and perception of illness in acute stroke patients

“…For instance, in a study on illness perception among critically ill patients in US, African-Americans tend to be more optimistic compared to Caucasian patients (Ford et al 2010) [21]. Another study on illness perception among breast cancer patients in Netherlands and Japan showed stronger concern about the illness in Japanese subjects [22]. It is crucial for clinicians to be aware of this issue in order to have better communication with patients from different racial backgrounds.…”

Elicitation of health state utilities associated with varying severities of flares in Systemic Lupus Erythematosus

“…Within our study the lowest utility scores were often observed in the Japanese cohort, with the exception of the severe renal flare HS and the severe CNS flare HS. Previous studies, not specific to SLE, have shown EQ-5D derived utility scores vary on average by 0.24 between Japan and the UK – this may be due to cultural disparities [ 27 , 28 ]. Differences observed in utility scores may be reflective of differences in social preference weights between populations.…”