If Body Fatness is Under Physiological Regulation, Then How Come We Have an Obesity Epidemic?

Abstract

Life involves a continuous use of energy, but food intake, which supplies that energy, is episodic. Feeding is switched on and off by a complex array of predominantly gut-derived peptides (and potentially nutrients) that initiate and terminate feeding bouts. Energy is stored as glucose and glycogen to overcome the problem of the episodic nature of intake compared with the continuous demand. Intake is also adjusted to meet immediate changes in demands. Most animals also store energy as fat. In some cases, this serves the purpose of storing energy in anticipation of a known future shortfall (e.g., hibernation, migration, or reproduction). Other animals, however, store fat in the absence of such anticipated needs, and in this case the fat appears to be stored in preparation for unpredictable catastrophic shortfalls in supply. Fat storage, however, brings disadvantages as well as advantages, in particular an increased risk of predation. Hence, many animals seem to have evolved a dual intervention point system preventing them from storing too little or too much fat. The physiological basis of the lower intervention point is well established, but the upper intervention point is much less studied. Human obesity can potentially be understood in an evolutionary context as due to drift in the upper intervention point following release from predation 2 million years ago (the drifty gene hypothesis) combined with a stimulus in modern society to overconsume calories, possibly attempting to satisfy intake of a limiting microor macro-nutrient like protein (the protein leverage hypothesis).

RETRACTED ARTICLE: The ‘obesity paradox’ and survival after colorectal cancer: true or false?

“…Third, advantageous host-related factors may favor overweight compared with normal weight patients. In evolutionary terms, excess fat serves the purpose of storing energy in anticipation of known future shortfalls, such as hibernation, migration, or reproduction [20]. In a similar manner, patients with moderate amounts of excess adiposity may better combat the physiological stresses of cancer treatment.…”

Behavioural and physiological responses of wood mice (Apodemus sylvaticus) to experimental manipulations of predation and starvation risk

“…Although the hormone leptin, produced primarily in white adipose tissue [7,8] has been often suggested to be the peripheral fat signal in this model, a central location for the 'set point' has never been identified. Moreover, this model is in conflict with observations of the patterns of changes in animal and human body weight [9,10] not least of which is the obesity epidemic itself [2].…”

“…Resting metabolic rate was estimated as the average value of the five lowest consecutive readings (equivalent to 2 min and 30 s in the chamber) [24], and the average of the measurements made on consecutive days was used for further analysis. VO 2 was calculated after Depocas and Hart [25] as VO 2 …”

Food intake and appetite following school-based high-intensity interval training in 9–11-year-old children

“…Any sustained imbalance between energy intake and expenditure will result either in loss of weight (Jequier and Tappy, 1999;Schwartz, 2012;Speakman, 2014), or attainment of a positive energy balance, ultimately leading to weight gain and obesity. Previous work has often involved controlled, laboratory-based protocols to manipulate and examine acute food intake responses to physical activity (Bozinovski et al, 2008;Dodd, Welsman, and Armstrong, 2008).…”