Identifying Outliers in Response Quality Assessment by Using Multivariate Control Charts Based on Kernel Density Estimation

Abstract

When monitoring industrial processes, a Statistical Process Control tool, such as a multivariate Hotelling T 2 chart is frequently used to evaluate multiple quality characteristics. However, research into the use of T 2 charts for survey fieldwork–essentially a production process in which data sets collected by means of interviews are produced–has been scant to date. In this study, using data from the eighth round of the European Social Survey in Belgium, we present a procedure for simultaneously monitoring six response quality indicators and identifying outliers: interviews with anomalous results. The procedure integrates Kernel Density Estimation (KDE) with a T 2 chart, so that historical “in-control” data or reference to the assumption of a parametric distribution of the indicators is not required. In total, 75 outliers (4.25%) are iteratively removed, resulting in an in-control data set containing 1,691 interviews. The outliers are mainly characterized by having longer sequences of identical answers, a greater number of extreme answers, and against expectation, a lower item nonresponse rate. The procedure is validated by means of ten-fold cross-validation and comparison with the minimum covariance determinant algorithm as the criterion. By providing a method of obtaining in-control data, the present findings go some way toward a way to monitor response quality, identify problems, and provide rapid feedbacks during survey fieldwork.

Spatial Pattern and Influencing Factors of Intangible Cultural Heritage of Music in Xiangxi, Central China

“…Krn r S r aiyS r iamtiar S ht S ihrS t vt it r S rlS ihnrr-amr ar t ,S a ieaiavr,S ama rSt Sha hSanria ar S [16][17][18],St SaiSht Slrr Swa r ySe r Sa Smt ySlar S [19][20][21][22].S Cr rqer i y,Skrn r S r aiySr iamtiar Swt St rair SirSrvt etirSihrS r aiySrlSICHM ,S t Sai Sit ie tiar Slrnme tSa St Slr rw :…”