“…Mineral textural analyses of avian eggshell using Xray analysis and polarized light show no evidence that ACC is present in completed, laid calcitic eggshell (Rodriguez-Navarro et al, 2007). More recently, this same group found no ACC phase in crystal growth studies in vitro (Hemandez-Hemandez et al, 2008), although others growing calcium carbonate in vitro observed its transient presence when quail eggshell proteins were present (Lakshminarayanan et al, 2006). Despite this for avian eggshell, in the case of calcium carbonate sea urchin spine and larval skeleton, for example, higher resolution studies show that the ''single crystal" biominerals are actually a mosaic of domains delimited by distinct or occluded organic proteinaceous layers (Berman et al, 1988(Berman et al, , 1990 and contain transient ACC (Wilt, 1999(Wilt, , 2002.…”