Thioindigo (2-(3-Oxo-1-benzothiophen-2(3H)-ylidene)-1-benzothiophen-3(2H)-one) is a synthetic dye related to the natural compound Indigo. Notwithstanding the interest aroused recently by its employment as a functional material in a number of applications, a satisfactory characterization of its solid state is still missing. In this work, we study the occurrence of the two thioindigo α and β polymorphs under various growth conditions, and find that their structural similarity implies they often coexist. However, whereas polymorph β is certainly predominant in the bulk phase, polymorph α grows preferentially on substrates, turning out to be the surface stabilized phase in highly homogeneous and ordered films obtained by the bar-assisted meniscus shearing method (BAMS). DFT calculations support the experimental findings, aiding in the polymorph spectroscopic identification and to the interpretation of the order in the films of polymorph α.