Search citation statements
Paper Sections
Citation Types
Year Published
Publication Types
Relationship
Authors
Journals
Historical sources written in the Ottoman period reflect the necessary information about the economic, social, moral and religious aspects of the period. In these works, it is possible to see the religious understanding of the society and scholars of the period in which they were written because these works convey both historical information and reflect the social and religious structures of their period. Some Ottoman historians use verses and traditions (ahādith) to strengthen them with a religious basis while describing the events. In this study, the Qur’ānic verses that some Ottoman historians used in their works and the interpretations that some commentators brought to these verses are given. When the lives of Ottoman historians are examined, it is seen that they have something to say about every subject, especially about reli-gion and history. Ottoman historians skillfully used the verses of the Qur' ān and traditions (ahādith) in the events they narrated in their works, and sometimes they took the whole verse or sometimes a part of it. Ottoman historians revealed different meanings and interpretations from the meaning of the verse in the context of its revelation, and they repeated the same ver-ses from time to time. The historians reported the events in an objective way, avoiding prejudi-ces. In general, commentators have taken into account the environment of revelation while interpreting the verses. Ottoman historians, used the verses according to the flow of events. For this reason, it has been seen that some verses are used differently from the revelation environ-ment. The works of Ottoman historians, who included the verses of the Qur' ān in their works, were examined, and at the result of this examination, the message they wanted to give and the interpretation of some commentators on the same verse were compared. In the study, the text of the Ottoman historians about the event in which the verse takes place is given as summary, both the commentators' interpretation of the verse and an evaluation at the end is made.
Historical sources written in the Ottoman period reflect the necessary information about the economic, social, moral and religious aspects of the period. In these works, it is possible to see the religious understanding of the society and scholars of the period in which they were written because these works convey both historical information and reflect the social and religious structures of their period. Some Ottoman historians use verses and traditions (ahādith) to strengthen them with a religious basis while describing the events. In this study, the Qur’ānic verses that some Ottoman historians used in their works and the interpretations that some commentators brought to these verses are given. When the lives of Ottoman historians are examined, it is seen that they have something to say about every subject, especially about reli-gion and history. Ottoman historians skillfully used the verses of the Qur' ān and traditions (ahādith) in the events they narrated in their works, and sometimes they took the whole verse or sometimes a part of it. Ottoman historians revealed different meanings and interpretations from the meaning of the verse in the context of its revelation, and they repeated the same ver-ses from time to time. The historians reported the events in an objective way, avoiding prejudi-ces. In general, commentators have taken into account the environment of revelation while interpreting the verses. Ottoman historians, used the verses according to the flow of events. For this reason, it has been seen that some verses are used differently from the revelation environ-ment. The works of Ottoman historians, who included the verses of the Qur' ān in their works, were examined, and at the result of this examination, the message they wanted to give and the interpretation of some commentators on the same verse were compared. In the study, the text of the Ottoman historians about the event in which the verse takes place is given as summary, both the commentators' interpretation of the verse and an evaluation at the end is made.
Kur’an-ı Kerim’in doğru anlaşılmasının önemli bir yolu, Kur’an-Sünnet ilişkisinin kurulması ve bunun doğru bir şekilde yapılmasıdır. Zira Kur’an’ın ilk ve en önemli muhatabı Hz. Peygamberdir. Ayrıca o, müminler için örnek gösterilmiştir. Dolayısıyla onun Kur’an’a dair tefsirleri, yorumları ile fiilleri ve onayları çok önem-lidir. Ancak Kur’an-Sünnet ilişkisi kurulurken sünnetle ayetin aynı konuyla ilgili olduğuna dikkat edilmeli, Hz. Peygamber’in istişhad mahiyetindeki bir yorumu tefsir olarak ele alınarak ayetin yanlış anlaşılmasına neden olunmamalıdır. Ayetlerin kolay anlaşılması, öncelikle ayetlerin iniş zamanının ve indirilmelerine vesile olan soru, sorun ve olayların tespit edilmesine bağlıdır. Bu da ayetlerin anlaşılmasının dış bağlamlarını bil-mekle mümkün olduğunu göstermektedir. Ayrıca ayetlerin birçoğunun tek başına değil, bir ayet grubunda indirilmesi, bu ayet grubunun tespitini de gerekli kılmıştır. Çalışmada, Meryem suresi 19/96. ayeti bağlamın-da Kur’an’ın doğru anlaşılmasının yol ve yöntemleri hakkında bilgi verilmiş, ayetin doğru anlaşılmasının üzerinde durulmuş ve buna yönelik olarak da ayetin dış ve iç bağlamı tespit edilmeye çalışılmıştır. Ardından Kur’an-Sünnet ilişkisi ele alınmış, ayetin yanlış anlaşılmasına neden olan rivayetler irdelenmiş, rivayetlerin senetleriyle birlikte metin tenkidinin önemine işaret edilerek rivayetleri doğru anlama konusu üzerinde du-rulmuştur. Daha sonra ayetin tefsirinde rivayetlerin etkisinde kalan veya literal ve parçacı bir anlayışla ayete yaklaşan müfessirler ile ayetin dış ve iç bağlamına dikkat çeken müfessirlerin tefsir/yorumları hakkında bilgi verilmiştir. Sonuçta ise istişhad mahiyetindeki hadisleri tefsir olarak ele almanın, ayetlerin yanlış anlaşılması-na, doğru anlamın kaybolmasına veya ikinci plana atılmasına neden olduğu, müfessirlerin önemli bir kısmı-nın bu tür hadislerden etkilenerek ayetleri bağlamlarından kopuk bir şekilde ele aldıkları belirtilmiştir.
Öz: Hz. Peygamber Kur’ân’ın anlaşılmasında tartışmasız bir otoritedir. Hz. Peygamber’in Kur’ân ayetlerini beyan ederken bir tebyin yönteminin olup olmadığı meselesi, bu araştırmanın problemidir. Makalede amaçlanan, İnsân Sûresi örnekliğinde, rivayet ihtilafları özelinde, Hz. Peygamber’in tebyin yönteminin tespitidir. Bu doğrultuda bu ihtilafların incelenmesiyle, Kur’an’ın tamamında söz konusu edilebilecek bir yöntemden söz edilip edilemeyeceği araştırılacaktır. Makalemizde temel bilimsel araştırma yöntemimiz tümevarımdır. Sureye dair rivayet ihtilaflarına ait veriler başlıklandırılak incelenecek, sonuçları değerlendirilecektir. Sonuç olarak araştırmamızda elde edilen veriler doğrultusunda Hz. Peygamber’in sünnetinde tebyinin konumu, tebyinin yöntem olarak değeri ve imkânı, sonraki nesildeki durumu tartışılacaktır. Anahtar Kelimeler: İnsan Sûresi, Tefsir, Rivâyet, İhtilaf, Tebyin Yöntemi. Abstract: The Prophet is an indisputable authority in the understanding of the Qur'an. The question of whether there is a method of tabyin when the Prophet declares the verses of the Qur'an is the problem of this research. For the purpose of the article, in the example of Sūrat al-Insān , in the context of narration disputes, the Prophet. It is the determination of the method of the tabyin of the Prophet. In this direction, by examining these disputes, it will be investigated whether a method that can be mentioned in the entire Qur'an can be mentioned. In our article, our basic scientific research method is induction. The data related to the narration disputes related to the Sūrat will be examined under the heading and the results will be evaluated. As a result, in line with the data obtained in our research, the position of the subject in the Sunnah of the Prophet, the value and possibility of the subject as a method, and its status in the next generation will be discussed. Keywords: Sūrah al-Insān, Tafsīr, Narration, Disagreement, Tabyīn method.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
hi@scite.ai
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.