Researchers have repeatedly noted a flange of bone along the distodorsoradial margin of the Neandertal first metacarpal diaphysis, marking the insertion of the opponens pollicis muscle. It has been argued that this flange represents both greater muscle volume and greater leverage for the opponens pollicis. Here we assess the potential for increased mechanical effectiveness of the opponens pollicis in rotation and abduction in Neandertals as compared with Middle Paleolithic, Mid Upper Paleolithic, and recent modern humans. The radial displacement of the insertion for the opponens pollicis was assessed as a proxy for the moment arm for this muscle in rotation and abduction. Radial protrusion, both absolute and scaled to body size, was found to be greater in Neandertals and the Middle Paleolithic modern humans as compared with more recent humans, suggesting greater mechanical effectiveness of this muscle in Middle Paleolithic populations. This pattern may be the result of increased technological advancement after the Middle Paleolithic, resulting in a decreased need for muscular strength.
INTRODUCTION
Paleoanthropologists have noted several aspects of the Neandertal upper limb that likely signify the ability to produce larger joint torques compared to those of early and recent modern humans. These include increased scapular spine height, more medial orientation of the radial tuberosity, increased diaphyseal curvature of the radius, relative lengthening of the neck of the radius, increased palmar tuberosities of the scaphoid, trapezium and hamate, pollical phalangeal proportions, and opponens flanges on the external diaphyses of metacarpals 1 and 5 (Churchill and Rhodes 2006;Hambücken 1993; Musgrave 1971;Trinkaus 1983Trinkaus , 2006Trinkaus and Churchill 1988;Villemeur 1994). These differences would theoretically increase joint leverage, allowing Neandertals to have generated larger joint torques for a given muscle volume. In particular, one of these features, the bony flange on the distodorsoradial margin of the metacarpal 1 diaphysis, has been argued to reflect both an hypertrophy of and a greater moment arm for the opponens pollicis muscle.The presence of a prominent opponens flange on the Neandertal distodorsoradial metacarpal 1 diaphysis for the opponens pollicis (OP) muscle has been repeatedly noted since it was first highlighted by Sarasin (1932), in both mature individuals (Bonch-Osmolovskij 1941;Heim 1982a;Kimura 1976; Musgrave 1971;Trinkaus 1983;Vandermeersch 1991;Villemeur 1994;Vlček 1975Vlček , 1978 and young Neandertals (Heim 1982b;Vlček 1975). It has been used to infer an hypertrophy of the OP muscle (BonchOsmolovskij 1941;Heim 1982a;Trinkaus 1983;Vlček 1975), although the size and rugosity of the muscle insertion area on the radiopalmar edge of the flange can be relatively easily matched among early and recent modern humans (Kimura 1976). It was further suggested (Trinkaus 1983: 274) that it might have increased the moment arm of the muscle, an hypothesis that remains untested.Given that the O...