How Many Doses of Diphtheria Toxoid Are Required for Protection in Adults? Results of a Case‐Control Study among 40‐ to 49‐Year‐Old Adults in the Russian Federation

Abstract

During the Russian diphtheria epidemic of the 1990s, adults had an unexpectedly high rate of disease. A retrospective, matched case-control study was done to measure the effectiveness of one, two, or three or more doses of diphtheria toxoid against diphtheria among 40- to 49-year-old Russians. Thirty-nine diphtheria case-patients and 117 controls were studied. Previous vaccinations were included if one dose was received within the previous 10 years. Five cases (13%) and 33 controls (28%) had received three or more doses of vaccine. The matched odds ratio was 0.3 (95% confidence interval, 0.1-0.9) for three or more doses compared with no doses, which was a vaccine effectiveness of 70% (95% confidence interval, 10-90). A trend existed toward milder disease with increasing doses (chi2 test for trend, P=.02). The results suggest that Russian adults, who were unlikely to have acquired immunity to diphtheria through immunization or natural infection, required at least three doses of diphtheria toxoid for reliable protection against disease.

Immunogenicity and Safety of Diphtheria-tetanus Vaccine in Adults

“…These results are compatible to previous studies which revealed that more doses of Td vaccination could provide more protective immunity and prevent development of severe diseases, especially for diphtheria (17-19). These studies provided valuable data about the effect of Td vaccine on diphtheria, especially after a large outbreak in the former Soviet Union, but the effect on tetanus was not evaluated.…”

Diphtheria toxin IgG levels in military and civilian blood donors in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

“…During an epidemic in Eastern Europe the highest mortality rate (62%) was detected among persons aged 41 to 64 years (15). Nowadays, booster doses of diphtheria toxoid in Brazil and many other countries are recommended every 10 years for adults, but this recommendation is not regularly enforced (6,15).…”

Diphtheria-neutralizing antibody levels in healthy adults from Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

“…During epidemic in Eastern Europe the highest mortality rate (62%) was also detected in this age group (Rakhmanova et al 1996, Brennan et al 2000, Ohuabunwo et al 2005.…”