How Have International Business Discourses on the Environment Changed over the Last Decade?

Abstract

One group of discourses often neglected within the study of international environmental politics are those of business actors. Comparing two key events in international environmental politics, the 1992 Rio Earth Summit and the 2002 Johannesburg Earth Summit, provides an excellent opportunity to examine the changing character of business discourse over time. This article systematically analyses and compares the business–environment discourses of two books written for the summits respectively, representing the view of the international business community: Changing Course(1992) and Walking the Talk (2002). The comparison of both texts reveals some continuity but also major changes. One area of continuity is that business discourses on the environment attempt to mask a traditionally antagonistic view of environmental issues. Major changes include an increasing willingness to reach accommodation with environmental non-governmental organizations and a desire to overcome business's traditionally defensive, reactive role. Characterizing this is the adoption of a proactive approach to shaping the international environmental agenda. The article also discusses the significance of these findings for our understanding of the environmental role of business in a globalized society.

Against corporate responsibility: critical reflections on thinking, practice, content and consequences

“…Our critical approach consists of two main steps: (1) a theoretical analysis of CR HA , drawing on mainstream CR literature, with a specifi c focus on what we see as one of the most infl uential driving forces behind CR HA (see also Corporate Watch, 2006;Rutherford, 2006), the World Business Council of Sustainable Development (WBCSD); and (2) illustrations of our main theoretical points as expressed in the case of a member of WBCSD, Botnia (as part of the Metsäliitto group). For these illustrations we rely on different types of secondary material, including documents made available by Botnia (2006Botnia ( , 2007 and Faroppa and Annala (2004), NGO and watchdog communication (Pierri, 2006), more general printed, electronic and visual media accounts, as well as our own observations during two events: (1) the screening of a documentary fi lm titled La historia de dos orillas ('The story of two shores') and the panel discussion that followed at the Helsinki Film Festival in September 2006; and (2) the OtaEco congress in November 2006 where the CR representative of Botnia spoke on the case of Fray Bentos (Annala, 2006).…”

Communicating business greening and greenwashing in global media: A multimodal discourse analysis of CNN’s greenwashing video

“…Lately, images together with their interplay with other semiotic modes have received a much more prominent role in environmental research. So, among the latest explorations of environmental discourses across various media and genres could be mentioned not only the comparative analysis of environmental business discourses (Rutherford, 2006), the genre analysis of corporate environmental reports (Skulstad, 2008), or the critical historical analysis of political discourses dealing with environmental issues (Reisigl and Wodak, 2009), but also the multimodal discourse analyses of the green collection of Getty images (Hansen and Machin, 2008), green advertising (Hansen, 2010), educational films (Maier, 2009b) and corporate videos (Maier, forthcoming). Nevertheless, taking into consideration the urgency of the contemporary environmental problems and the ways in which they often continue to be represented in a dramatically increasing number of environmental discourses, it seems obvious that a wider range of media texts focused on environmental topics like greenwashing, for example, should be dealt with by deploying approaches that address the complex meaning-making interplay of several semiotic modes.…”