Identifying the proper carbon material
is one of the key requirements
in developing high-performance supercapacitor electrodes. Carbon nanotubes
(CNTs), graphene nanoplatelets (GNPs), and graphite (Gr) are commonly
used carbon allotropes for supercapacitor applications. The performance
of those materials depends on the electrolyte used and the operating
potential window. However, those parameters have rarely been investigated
and explained. Herein, we present a roadmap for the proper selection
of carbon materials in supercapacitor applications via the investigation
of the behavior of CNTs, GNPs, and Gr in different electrolytes using
both electrochemical and computational tools. The charge storage mechanism
was found to be electrolyte-dependent. In terms of the operating potential
window, the best performance was obtained upon the use of a Na2SO4 electrolyte, which enabled a potential window
of −1 to 0.9, while in terms of capacitance, the positive electrodes
in a H2SO4 electrolyte exhibited the highest
capacitance. H2SO4 enabled keto–enol
tautomerism in the positive potential window and can enlarge the potential
window to 1 V. Quantum capacitance calculations helped to identify
the reasons behind the obtained different performances in the negative
and positive potential windows. For example, upon the identification
of the proper electrolyte and potential window, it was possible to
obtain a capacitance as high as 453.60 F/g at 5 mV/s in a potential
window of 1 V for CNTs, which are much higher than those reported
in the literature. Moreover, the guidelines were successfully used
to develop a symmetric device that delivers a specific energy of 23.3
Wh/kg and a specific power of 475 W/kg with a stability of 97.8% after
5000 cycles over a potential window of 1.9 V, which are much higher
than those reported for CNTs-based symmetric devices.