Higher Education as a Gift and as a Commons

Abstract

This paper takes as a starting point Lewis Hyde's (2007, xvi) assertion that art is a gift and not a commodity: "Works of art exist simultaneously in two 'economies', a market economy and a gift economy. Only one of these is essential, however: a work of art can survive without a market, but where there is no gift there is no art." I want to argue that the same claim should be made for those aspects of academic labour that refer to teaching and education. Education can survive without a market, but where there is no gift there is no education. However the gift that is part of all educational processes gets rather obscured in regimes where higher education is either a public good or a private good. In regimes of higher education as public good the gift gets obscured by the provision of a service by the state. In regimes of higher education as a private good (e.g. higher education in the UK) the gift gets even more obscured, obviously so. It is only in a third educational regime, where education is a common good (e.g. the recent rise of the free universities), that the gift character of education can properly shine. Whilst this should be celebrated, the notion of a higher education commons poses some severe challenges. The paper ends with an examination of possibilities of academic activists to rescue or even strengthen the gift-like character of education.

Reviewing the Complexities of Student Non-Attendance and the Implications for Block Teaching

“…Such guidance would partly take the form, as Blair (2017) raises, of: successful navigation around the digital environment; developing academic literacy; creating social engagement opportunities; and, being trained in how to use feedback effectively. Ultimately, following Wittel (2018), it is important that we see HE as part of a 'gift' to society, a common good. This gift can be seen as a transformative action rather than simply a turn to an educational consumer action.…”

Is ‘Deschooling Society’ Possible? Notes from the Field

“…Information flow has thus been increasing exponentially, and knowledge infrastructures have become an elemental component of today's societies. However, due to the privatization surge, a wide array of enclosures has been taking place, threatening to convert knowledge and learning from a resource and a process available for all to an advantage of the few (Korsgaard 2019;Wittel 2018). At the same time, people with access to networked computers self-organize, collaborate, and produce shared resources and their governance systems, i.e., a commons (Bauwens et al 2019;Bauwens and Jandrić 2021).…”

Organising an Alternative University: A Reflection on the Conference ‘Critical, Emancipatory and Solidarist Endeavors’

“…The struggle to return the academy to the universities and to return the universities to the people continues in, against and beyond institutions and as part of a larger project to reclaim the general commons (Wittel 2016). Liberatory educators and alternative world-makers across the world have much to learn from it.…”