Healthy viewing: the reception of medical narratives

Abstract

This paper draws on two reception studies. One focuses on an American medical drama which respondents perceived as entertainment but also as a reliable source of information from which they collected medical and social data by using emotional and ludic strategies. The second compares parallel illness narratives in a soap opera and a documentary. Soap operas were described by informants as good pedagogic tools because they attracted large audiences and promoted identification and repetition which enhance learning. On the other hand, they criticised the documentary for being incomplete and artificial. The conclusion argues that viewers are media-literate, astute and insightful. They produce sophisticated, subtle interpretations which cannot be predicted by content analyses of programmes alone. More reception research is therefore needed, particularly since television is increasingly omnipresent and provides a considerable portion of the public's medical knowledge.

Influence of Evidence Type and Narrative Type on HPV Risk Perception and Intention to Obtain the HPV Vaccine

“…These findings are again in line with the Winterbottom et al (2008) review and support the growing body of literature examining the influence of narrative point of view on its persuasive impact (e.g., de Graaf et al, 2012;Kaufman & Libby, 2012). With these findings, our study also answers the broader call in the literature for research that examines the nuances of narrative influence (Dahlstrom, 2010;Davin, 2003).…”

Young people and television fiction. Reception analysis

“…A similar attitude was observed by Davin (2003) in his reception analysis of American medical dramas. Even so, most participants admitted that programs are an inspiration when facing certain personal and socialization problems.…”

(De)stigmatizing the Silent Epidemic: Representations of Hearing Loss in Entertainment Television

“…Studies have shown that this medium has been especially effective in informing viewers of health issues and influencing behavior (Brodie et al, 2001;Gauthier, 1999;Glik et al, 1998;Singhal & Rogers, 2004;Winsten, 1994). In fact, Davin (2004) found that viewers were more likely to believe the messages in fictional medical dramas than in health documentaries. Unlike news stories, which may only address an issue for a few minutes, fictional television can devote full episodes or even seasons to a health issue, thereby presenting the entire emotional experience, from the initial diagnosis through the treatment process (Gauthier, 1999;Schwitzer, 2004).…”