Healthcare quality for Muslims: TCCM and TSR frameworks analyses

Abstract

Purpose Transformative service research (TSR) has received considerable attention from researchers and marketers in recent years and becomes a research priority in health care. In response, this paper adapts the TSR entities and wellbeing framework to systematically review healthcare quality research on Muslim consumers. The purpose of this paper is to identify research gaps and provide directions for future research, aligning healthcare studies with the TSR framework. Design/methodology/approach The authors of this paper reviewed empirical papers in healthcare quality research on Muslim patients between the years 2000 and 2020. The recorded journal articles were synthesized using insights from the TSR framework. Several literature gaps were identified and future research directions were provided using the TCCM framework, in which T stands for theory, C for context, C for characteristics and M for methodology. Findings This paper finds studies that encompass several domains of the TSR framework including cultural and religious dimensions, service interaction and customer engagement dimensions and customer service wellbeing. Findings also reveal subject matters related to the TSR framework, which receive less attention in the healthcare literature. A number of potential avenues for theoretical extension in health care are also discussed. Social implications The implications of this paper are highly relevant to Muslim healthcare consumers, the healthcare system and society in general. The findings suggest inspiring changes in the healthcare ecosystem that yields a greater quality of life (health and wellbeing) for individuals and their respective communities. Originality/value This paper advances the current state of healthcare research by identifying and organizing components of TSR entities and wellbeing framework, using Muslim patients as the context. It enhances some pioneering approaches within the domain of TSR and quality dynamics and provides a holistic perspective as guidance and systematic thinking to further advancement in the field of services marketing and Islamic marketing.

Trust factors and their impact on patients satisfaction of private clinics in city of Ramadi - Iraq

“…H2: It states (There is a statistically significant effect of efficiency on patient satisfaction), as a one-unit increase in patient contact, increases patient satisfaction by (0.204), S.E (0.053), and C.R (3,874), This validates the first sub-hypothesis, and it is congruent with the findings of another research [31], a study [15] and a study [65].…”

“…He communicates verbally and nonverbally with the doctor by showing sympathy and acting politely, listening well, and with patients [1]. In the same direction, it was also defined as the extent to which the medical service provider actively listened to patients' concerns, and explained things in ways that could be understood and treated with kindness, appreciation, and respect [31]. Communication provides positive results or benefits to different parties, as effective communication between the doctor (medical provider) and patients improves diagnosis in general, increases patients' commitment to the doctor's recommendations and medications provided, enhances a better understanding between them, helps to call or evoke medical information and understand it well, improves the handling of the disease and affects and increases patient satisfaction with the medical provider [15,32].…”

A systematic literature review on transformative practices and well-being outcomes in healthcare service

“…While numerous SLRs have explored various aspect of TSR (i.e. Rahman, 2021; Islam et al. , 2022; Previte and Robertson, 2019; McCall-Kennedy et al.…”

Assessing consumer preferences on halal service: the emergence of Sharia hospitals for Muslim consumer

“…Previous studies in Sharia-based service were about tourism and hospitality (Berakon et al , 2021; Mursid and Wu, 2021; Vargas-Sánchez and Moral-Moral, 2019), banking or finance (Marzuki and Nurdin, 2020) and insurance (Ratnawati et al , 2020). Studies on health care discussed under the Sharia perspective were also mainly focused on service quality (Islam et al , 2021; Ratnawati et al , 2020), which directs the discussions into the service providers’ perspectives. Meanwhile, the global Muslim market shows rising demand from the customer side of Sharia service (Dinar Standard, 2022).…”